Team Members: Abbey Johnson, Nick Nolan, Isabella DeSario
You developed a very strong thesis that has a clear purpose and can be substantiated with the quotes that you selected. It is great how you chose a course that you truly believe can be improved and you seem to have a thought out plan to improve this course for the future. Also, the idea to turn FYE into a career development course is something unique that would surely benefit a large number of students.
It might be a good idea to lose the second half of you thesis. Though the quote you incorporated into your thesis is related to what you are discussing, it isn’t quite strong enough to be the key point from which you draw all of your ideas. We suggest using this quote later on in your development to substantiate the claims you originally make. Also, we recommend cutting the “we believe” statement from the end of your thesis. You are making a good point, but the statement is weak on its own. Try incorporating it into the rest of your thesis differently.
]]>substantial feedback: strong thesis, we like your idea with what to do with FYE. We think this will benefit all students not just students that fall in the liberal arts category.
Constructive criticism: The quote used in your thesis sounds more like a supporting detail that you could use later in your paper, and maybe not in your thesis.
Jenna: Great ideas on how to improve FYE, and not focusing just on the liberal arts tradition
Kenzie: I agree with your thesis and think that most students would benefit more if FYE was set up as a career fair.
]]>