Positive: Good choice to include Freire right off the bat, just make sure to apply his writing where it’d work best.
Negative: The only issue I see with this is if the students aren’t motivated or have a lack of incentive to truly discuss with one another.
Use of Percy: As mentioned before you want to be able to apply Percy and Freire to your analysis of teaching without teaching, I’d recommend writing out what you have, then read over the essay, pick where you’d think each quote would work best.