Praise: Your team’s paper is very well written and I believe you have ample support from Percy’s essay to back your body paragraph topics you are trying to hit.
Constructive: The only thing I would say that could use a little strength and more detail to it would be your thesis. You lack the points your are trying to hit in your thesis itself.
Percy: I believe you show plenty of proof and excellent quotes from Percy’s essay. He would agree with your team’s paper and you do a great job of showing that in your paper.