The teacher and student relationship at West Chester University is similar to most schools. The teacher gives information to the student and the student is told to memorize and to repeat the information on an exam or project. Freire is a Brazilian teacher and philosopher who believes that the education system is horrific. A few ways Freire thinks the teacher and student relationship should be changed are the student should try talking about the lesson as though they were teaching it and the student should not memorize, but instead learn the material.
Freire believes that the student will learn nothing unless he/she can teach it him/herself. The teacher teaching is just a waste of time for everyone except the teacher because at the end of the day the teacher is the only one who learned. Students cannot learn the material unless they can teach the material. This way of teaching is referred to as the “Banking Concept” when the teacher teaches and the students listen. Freire says, “The banking approach to adult education, for example, will never propose to students that they critically consider reality (Freire 2). This phrase says a lot about Freire’s ideology on this topic. To summarize he states that students do not think critically when in class or doing homework, thus the Banking concept is debunked. The banking concept may work for some who truly want to succeed , but the rest will surely fall behind. At West Chester University, the teacher/professor relationship is indistinguishable from other schools. They all use the banking concept. To change this professors at West Chester University can assign students to teach other students similar to the tutoring center. When a student presenting a topic in class that student is teaching, thus he/she is learning. Instead of having a final exam the student should teach the teacher a little bit of what they learned that simester. That would show actual understanding. Instead of doing math on a test the student would help a student who does not know the material well or just show the teacher. For history class the student would talk about all the important dates in a war or time period. In science the students would make his/her own experiment and teach the teacher how to do it. Having the student teach would be a great and effective way to learn than to memorize and forget about the material the next day.
Students often forget the material for their next class which is bad when that class requires prior knowledge. If students didn’t memorize but indeed learned the material then maybe it wouldn’t be an issue.
David: Your main idea here is great for the topic you picked just make sure that you have quotes to back up your thesis from the text.
Haley: The solutions you picked are great but the third solution needs a little more clarification.
Seamus: Your thesis is weak you need to look at your solutions and build your thesis from those solutions.
David
I believe that you have a strong argument that goes right along with Freire’s ideas in his essay, but I think that having each and every student attempt to teach something that they learned as a final exam wouldn’t show full knowledge of everything they should have learned throughout a semester.
Jason
I think that your topic is more of how to change a class rather then the teacher-student relationship. I do like the ideas presented and having students teach what they have learned throughout a course is a great way to show knowledge of a subject.
constructive criticism: I think you should reword this sentence “A few ways Freire thinks the teacher and student relationship should be changed are the student should try talking about the lesson as though they were teaching it and the student should not memorize, but instead learn the material.”
I think you should restate the sentence rather than saying what students should do, and say how they will execute the thesis. Like in what ways does Freire want the student teacher relationship to be changed? Also when you say learn the material, how would they learn the material, through interaction? touch up transitions
positive reinforcement: you’ve got a stable and concise body paragraph that is strong!
Overall: You should go more in depth in the broader statements you make.
Bella – Your essay had a strong opening, however the effectiveness was diminished by the use of run-on sentences. Be careful of rambling and try to employ more sentence length variation. Please try to more sophisticated language; using words such as “bad” makes your argument sound elementary.
Noah – Focus on intertwining your own opinions into Freire’s ideologies. It will strengthen your argument and make your essay more cohesive. Right now it seems like there are two separate essays, however by integrating them together it will solidify your essay.