https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fMoWzrNzA0fyyjbWac2evqsqLAtMezatzPQmP5fRC3s/edit
Project 2 Draft 2 (800 words)
Draft #2 link
Draft #2
Draft 2 of Writing Project 2 (Link), Gabe Jasinski
800 word draft
Meghan Kidd and Samantha Pawluczyk
Randell Cream
Writing 120
08 November 2019
Teaching Without Teaching
In Walker Percy’s, “The Loss of the Creature”, he explains how the most effective way of learning is through the process of indirect learning. This means students are able to grasp the concept of a topic when it is brought to their attention in other ways than having to sit in a class and being lectured at by a professor. If a professor wants their students to truly learn a subject, they will create different ways of challenging his or her students into learning the topic inside and out. For example, microeconomics 112 is a three day class per week and consists of a teacher lecturing to the students for a fifty minute period. What if the agenda of the course changed: Mondays would be a lecturing day, Wednesdays would be an open discussion group with prompts created by the students themselves, and Fridays would be dedicated to fieldwork outside of the classroom. Requiring students to teach others and lead classes, partake in fieldwork once a week to give them real experience, and have a group discussion in the classroom weekly are all ways to get the students to learn without being taught.
The main goal of each professor is to get their students to fully understand their topic for the specific class in which they are taking. For example, a microeconomics professor works hard to break down economics in numerous ways to try to successfully have the students wrap their heads around how a business runs efficiently. One way of indirectly teaching his or her students, the economics professor could design a mandatory project where students are required to teach at least three other students about their major. By doing this, it forces the student to learn the topic more because they will need to be able to break it down and explain it. With this assignment, students will work to ensure they know the subject inside and out because they will have to teach it to students who do not take an economics class at all. However, this will not educate the other students who are not taking economics, rather the idea of this project is to teach the economic students without having to sit in a class and listen to their professor lecture at them day after day.
Aside from teaching students who do not take economics, another method teachers could use to get his or her student engaged in class is to have student-led classes. In order to be most efficient, it is recommended by the professor to work in groups of three or four. As students work in groups, this allows them to bounce ideas off one another which helps to indirectly teach each other. This course will be held three times a week and with that, there will be allotted time for each student group to lead a lesson at the beginning of each class. The groups will be in a rotation so each class has a new group presenting a lesson for about 20-25 minutes. This amount of time gives the students the ability to teach their lesson but enough time for the professor to give a revised lesson to the class. In Percy’s article he explains, “If we look into the ways in which the student can recover the dogfish (or the sonnet), we will see that they have in common the stratagem of avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned and restoring access to sonnet and dogfish as beings to be known, reasserting the sovereignty of knower over known.” Here, Percy explains the idea of sovereignty and how it is the surrender of power to the experts. This connects to this idea of student-led lessons because the professor is surrendering his position in order to give that same power to his or her students.
Each week the students gather in a classroom on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays in the early morning hours at 8:00am to learn about their intended course, microeconomics 112. However, the question is, how much information are the students really absorbing during that time? This class is fifty minutes in length and consists of a group of thirty students that have grown tired due to the fact of an early morning class and a professor that lectures to them the whole time without holding any type of conversation. Therefore, every Friday class should be dedicated as a fieldwork day. If the students are given one day each week to have hands on learning in economics, they might be able to learn more because of the interactions they will be having. For example, in the beginning of the year the professor will make each student pick a local businesses in town to study how the store measures their supply and demand and other factors that keep the company in business. Additionally, they will be able to talk to the workers at the store and ask for advice about their future and their potential career in economics. In addition, the students will have to get a weekly form signed stating that they were present for an hour at the business of their choice to ensure that they were of attendance.
Furthermore, one last method that would indirectly teach students more about their subject would be to have weekly discussions between the students. The most effective way of holding these discussions would be to have a standard lecture on Monday, followed by the group discussions on Wednesday. The professor would give a certain amount of information on Monday and students would be required to come up with at least three questions regarding the lecture. This would help to get the students more involved in the lectures rather than going to class and zoning out. Students would have to submit their questions on D2L so when they arrived at class, they would be ready to go through the list of questions and converse. The benefits of this method of learning is to have students answer other students questions and teach one another. The professor would sit in on this discussion and chime in if there were any major questions to avoid getting off track. This is an effective way of learning because it is a form of teamwork which helps each student get a better understanding of the class.
Learning effectively in the classroom is sometimes hard due to some students just sitting at their desks inattentive and unfocused, while their professor is in the front of the room throwing words around that come natural to him or her, but are unknown to the students. However if the students are required to teach others and lead classes, partake in fieldwork once a week to give them real experience, and have an open group discussions so that they have the ability to actually learn the subject. By changing the layout of the class schedule, students are being given the best possible foundation to succeed. Students are the future and should be given the best possible teaching methods to prepare them for their upcoming careers.
Extended Draft
project 2 draft 2 (800 words)
Draft #2
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1THpYgo_kr5nXVTLLJOJ-zVNP0RsWJVMCRonnNtY5B6s/edit?usp=sharing
Samantha Weitzel, Katherine Sola, Leann Carroll
Draft 2 Project 2
Extended Draft Project #2
Draft #2 Topic 2 Riley & Gabby
Comments to Bella Bedore
Praise: I like how you elaborate on what these groups will be doing.
Constructive: I would try to have a more clear thesis stating your points
Percy: I like how you incorporated Percy in this topic and how strong it supports your point.
Comments to Makayla Medycki, Maura Kelly and Gwen Jordan
Praise: Clubs is a great example of learning outside the classroom and I like how you incorporated your major into your example
Percy: I think this is a great use of Percy to really help support your idea.
Constructive: Provide examples to help support your point of a work study job.
Writing project #2 – topic 1 draft 2
Education Beyond the Major
If a student at West Chester University is majoring in physics, then why should they have to take an art class. It would seem to be a waste of time, unless there is a justified reason. Students seem to moan at the thought of taking a class they don’t feel is necessary to their degree, but in reality it could help them in the long run. Walker Percy is an author who talks about these topics of education in his passage called The Loss of the Creature. Even though Percy never directly writes it down, he is pushing this message of education beyond a students major. West Chester is no exception. Most of the students time at West Chester University are spent outside their major because it helps them learn indirectly through mistakes, challenges them in ways they aren’t used to or familiar with, helps them find weaknesses to fix and puts them in unfamiliar situations.
There is a saying that in order to succeed in life you have to fail first. Humans learn from their mistakes than from their successes. A physics major might find math and sciences easy but when you give them a paint brush they might struggle. Percy says, “If the failures are “wrong” enough, as these are, they might still be turned to account as rueful conversation pieces”(3). This means that just because you fail doesn’t mean you are a failure. The art class is going to be a different type of hard for the physics major student and that will help them deal with situations like that for the future. Taking classes outside of the major prepares the student to not learn the material but know how to deal with situations they are not used too. At West Chester students need to take more classes to they are not used to to open them up to failure and from that failure come success and knowledge. Without these courses outside of the students major, the student might not be challenged enough to learn.
When a student is used a certain type of learning from the same subject and gets thrown into a new environment and type of teaching it can be challenges them in ways they aren’t used too and to learn. The content does not have to be hard. It can just be a different way of learning that is difficult. Percy says, “The great difficulty is that he is not aware that there is a difficulty”(4). This means that people should always expect and prepare for the worst but hope for the best. When that physics student walks into that art class with a bad attitude then they are going to end up with a bad grade. If someone thinks lightly of any class then they are going to be surprised with the difficulty level compared to if they prepared properly they would be fine. All students fall to this statement at some point in their educational career. Every student is not perfect in every subject and in every class. The reason to take classes outside of the major is to find those weaknesses and work/fix them.
Every student has a weakness. It could be anything as small as they can’t tie their shoes to a big as they can’t study for more than a minute. A lot of students bullshitted their way through high school. They never studied or tried because they didn’t have too. They never challenged themselves always taking easier classes. I also take fault. At West Chester University students are forced into these classes they need to study for and that is a defining time in student’s lives. It shows students true colors and work ethic by throwing them into a class they aren’t used too. For the students who then fail those classes, they need to take a look at themselves and fix their mistakes. For the students who flourish in these classes, they should feel pleased about there work/study habits. Percy has his own opinions on education that are unique and inlike most. He would agree with the statement that people would become better students if they succeed and overcome classes they didn’t want to take or thought were to hard to take. No one likes being put outside of their comfort and especially at school while paying lots of money.
Being put in an unfamiliar situation is tough for people. Maybe you are by yourself and don’t know anyone or you’re lost and and can’t ask for help. These situations are anxiety endorsing for most people. The first day for West Chester is set up to help the freshmen because there are no upperclassmen, but it’s still tough being in a new and unfamiliar place. Once classes start though all hell breaks loose. Students now have the most freedom they have ever felt in their life and also the most scared they have ever been. Taking hard and new classes are already enough pressure for students.
Bella DiPasquale – draft 2
revised extended draft
Kyle Owens
Topic 4 – project 2
What exactly is good teaching? This is a question that has gone unanswered for quite some time. Walker Percy and Friere(full name)(describe loss of creature and banking concept) have spent much time trying to answer this question. Although Percy and Freire both value the role of the teacher, they caution against the act of teaching. Freire states “The people subjected to domination must fight for their emancipation”. In this case the students have to fight for their education. From a students point of view I agree with many of the ideas of Percy and Freire. Professors should be able to cater the lesson plan to the specific needs of the students. Professors are able to support real student learning by teaching the class a way that increases student interaction, and will benefit students most, not the professors. Some ways real student learning can be implemented include project based learning, student led classes, personalized learning environments and (sub point 4 ). The most relevant idea that came to mind was implementing project based learning in the classroom.
Project based learning can be beneficial to many students, specifically those who struggle with standardized tests. Replacing standardized tests with projects students will be able to essentially teach themselves. Students will be able to work at their own specific pace that works best for them. Freire and percys views would strongly support this idea. Although Friere and Percy value teachers they believe in “avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned.” They would be more inclined to work on their own schedule in a way that is most productive to them. In addition to this students should have both options of working in groups or working independently, as students benefit from these options differently. When only one option is used some students are given an advantage, while others are put at a disadvantage. I believe that this is essential for this topic, all students know how they learn best. Percy believes not all students would benefit the same from the premade lesson plans and class rules that have been used for years in a row. Perhaps giving the students some leadership in the classroom can solve this problem.
Good teaching should include input from the students on how the class is run, as all students have their own unique ways they learn best. Students having more leadership in the classroom can lead to student run classes.In addition to this student led discussion groups and speeches may also be implemented. The way the class would be ran would stem from the thoughts and beliefs of the students themselves.As Percy has identified,‘”For there is nothing the educator can do to provide for this need of the student, everything the educator does only succeeds in becoming, for the student, part of the educational package.” In order to achieve teaching without teachers at West Chester University, classrooms need to become more student based and incorporate styles of learning that benefit each student individually. Students will better relate to each other when in a learning environment. Percy further proves this by stating “The educator is well aware that something is wrong, that there is a fatal gap between the students’ learning and students’ lives.” pg 4
College students have been taking classes for years now and are able to identify what learning styles will be most beneficial to them.
Another idea to encourage good learning includes letting individuals learn with students who share their same needs and preferences to create a more personalized learning environment.This can be implemented by a number of surveys to find strengths and weaknesses, and the best learning techniques. These different classes would include the same workload, they will be presented in a different manner. Classes with 200 different students sharing the same lesson plan seems non authentic. Percy reiterates this by stating,“It is now apparent that as between the many measures which may be taken to overcome the opacity, the boredom, of the direct confrontation of the thing or creature in its citadel of symbolic investiture, some are less authentic than others.” pg2 (talk ab instructional differences (relate a specific marketing 250 class to this and use examples )(take out park ab group work and non group work)
Sub point 4
“The educator whose business it is to teach students biology or poetry is unaware of a whole ensemble of relations which exist between the student and the dogfish and between the student and the Shakespeare sonnet.” pg4
In conclusion although Percy and freire value teachers, they believe in “avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned.” These ideas show that students themselves have more to offer in the classroom. The students should be a part of the teaching experience just as much as they are a part of the learning experience. By implementing project based learning, student led classes, personalized learning environments, and (sub point 4) students are able to receive a much more beneficial education
Comments on Sarah Veneziale and Caitlin Mangini Draft 2
constructive- “unnecessary factors involved” in the intro is confusing, you should elaborate on what these unnecessary factors are.
Percy- I like the quote about sovereignty and how you related it to the fact that courses are not made for everyone.
Praise- I like how you connected sovereignty to classes outside of ones major, I agree that the student has more power when they can choose classes they are not being forced to take, I would give an example of a major and a course outside of the major that benefits the student to make this stronger.
sarah veneziale and cait mangini 2nd draft
Education Outside of the Major
Thousands of people attend college every year, hoping to gain a successful job in the field they are studying in. Yet, majors only actually require 40-60 credits, leaving the student to take most classes outside of their chosen field. These additional classes lead the student to become more successful in their major, then they would if they weren’t going to take any courses other than their major. In The Loss of the Creature, written by Walker Percy, he highlights two major problems. One of them is that the student is at a loss of sovereignty and the other is that many courses are taught information with unnecessary factors involved. For the student to become the knower again can occur from the education outside of their major. By taking other classes not necessary for one’s major, they will become successful in learning how to learn, failing to succeed, trusting of the experts in their field.
The first advantage of taking classes outside one’s major is that the student will become an excellent learner. By taking so many classes and not just the 40-60 credits, it forces the student to sit in several classes. The student may not necessarily remember every detail they learn in every class, but they will know how they learned. A person never stops learning, no matter how old or experienced they are, and this is why becoming a learner is so critical. Walker Percy wrote, “It is only the hardiest and cleverest of students who can salvage the sonnet from this many-tissued package. It is only the rarest student who knows that the sonnet must be salvaged from the package” (Percy 4). The many-tissued package is also called the educational package, which is the information being taught to a student with several media involved. Medias such as surrounding noises, technology, and the teacher can all affect how one grasps the idea. Percy believes that if a student can remove all the media, then they are learning. This is a challenge and does not come easy. Taking the classes not directly related to a major gives more opportunity for a student to learn how to learn. Students must practice and through experience, will ultimately achieve it. The classes that may be deemed unnecessary or pointless, are potentially helping the students on becoming expert learners, and eventually experts in their field.
Secondly, taking multiple classes can, and most likely will, lead to failure in some. A student chooses a major because they are either interested or already good at that specific field or skill. However, when taking classes outside of one’s major, a student may be placed in a class they aren’t particularly good at or interested in. Failure in those courses brings a stronger sense of self. No one is an expert in everything, so by failing some classes, it only shows that the student can take the unnecessary course off their plate. There is no need for the stress that comes with trying to succeed in every class, and by overcoming that need, the student will become happier with their chosen major. The strength of not caring will ultimately lead to more success and focus on the student’s intended field of study. Walker Percy wrote, “ The loss of sovereignty takes this form: as a result of the science of botany, trees are not made available to every man” (Percy 6). This quote describes perfectly that not every course is made for everyone. A student has to be willing to focus on every subject in order to succeed in every field, but some fields aren’t made for them, just like Percy explains that not every tree is available to everyone. By taking extra classes, the student becomes more interested in their major, knowing that is the field of study for them. Failure in classes causes the student to love their major, gaining control of who they want to be.
The loss of sovereignty is a huge part of Percy’s message in his essay. This can be described by a loss of power and control of your own self. In taking classes outside of a student’s major, they would have more control of their sovereignty than they do when taking classes in their major. This is because students give more of their trust in the professor in their major since they want to learn as much as they can from the “experts.” In a class not in their major, students may not care as much to know about that particular topic, so they have more power over their learning. The student will not lose their sovereignty in this case because they aren’t as worried about becoming an expert on something they know they aren’t interested in, so they give more attention to their major. The student is strongest when they are not giving in to all of one professor’s ideas and expertise. In that case, the student is becoming the professor, not themselves. Walker Percy wrote, “A sovereignty of the knower—instead of being a consumer of a prepared experience, I am a sovereign wayfarer, a wanderer in the neighborhood of being who stumbles into the garden”(Percy 5). Percy shows that sovereignty is not in the prepared experience like a student’s major, but in the student being a wanderer, meaning the classes outside of their major. Noticing that students lose their sovereignty in classes in their major makes the student know that they really care about the field of study they choose and that they really want to pursue it in the future.
Comments on Olivia Vearling Draft 2
praise- I really like the connection between a job and transformative learning because people often forget the benefits of a job besides to make money.
constructive- how can teachers ensure that students are actually discussing the course content when they are not there to observe the discussion?
Percy- good quote from Percy about sovereign individuals and a good explanation- that students need experiences for themselves