https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TMtd9PLhlcGZz18Wm72UBVBs2EWPvqAdAu8kwnAzj4M/edit?usp=sharing
Category: Weekly Responses
peer review for Juliana B draft
praise – the idea of failure in areas explains very well why students need to take extra classes
constructive – Expanding more on the idea of how the students will struggle outside of their major may help better understand the paragraph
percy – adding a direct quote may help better connect your idea to percy
peer review for Adam Griffin draft
praise – Your introduction sets up the reader well. Your thesis is clear and well understood
construction – expand more on how you use the word “practice”
Percy- Add more on how your Percy quotes directly relates to how discussion groups will allow the students to tear apart the educational package
Draft comments for Bella Dipasquale
Praise: You have good ideas on how students can learn without being taught
Constructive: Some of your wording and sentencing is grammatically incorrect. Also is it in the hand of the teacher or the student to be learned.
Percy: Good quotes used throughout. Try to add more detail and use Percy more
Draft comments for Micheal Ramirez
Praise: Your intro is really good and I like how your quotes flow smoothly.
Constructive: Some grammatic errors
Percy: Some quotes do not say who they are from. Just add Percy’s name at the end of it. I like the quotes you chose.
Peer review
Michael Ramirez-
Constructive- Some awkward phrasing. Try to reread it and you should catch it.
Praise- Your intro is very well written. You also give lots of support for your ideas. Overall very well written.
Percy- Great use of Percy. Your transition from your quotes to your information is very smooth.
Peer review
Bella Dipasquale-
Constructive- Some wording is awkward throughout the whole paper.
Praise- Good ideas for how you are going to teach without teaching. Just add more details to support yourself.
Percy- Good use of Percy quotes to support what you are trying to say.
Sarah’s team draft 1
Thousands of people attend college every year, hoping to gain a successful job in the field they are studying in. Yet, majors only actually require 40-60 credits, leaving the student taking a majority of classes outside of their chosen field. In The Loss of the Creature, written by Walker Percy, a huge message is that taking classes outside of the major will indeed lead the student to become advantageous in their career. There are two major problems highlighted in Percy. One of them is that the student is at a loss of sovereignty and the other is that many courses are taught information with unnecessary factors involved. For the student to become the knower again can occur from the education outside of their major. By taking other classes not necessary for one’s major, they will become successful in learning how to learn, regain control over failing classes,
The first advantage of taking classes outside one’s major is that the student will become an excellent learner. By taking so many classes and not just the 40-60 credits, it forces the student to sit in several classes. The student may not necessarily remember every detail they learn in every class, but they will know how they learned. A person never stops learning, no matter how old or experienced they are, and this is why becoming a learner is so critical. Walker Percy wrote, “It is only the hardiest and cleverest of students who can salvage the sonnet from this many-tissued package. It is only the rarest student who knows that the sonnet must be salvaged from the package” (Percy 4). The many-tissued package is also called the educational package, which is the information being taught to a student with several media involved. Medias such as surrounding noises, technology, and the teacher can all affect how one grasps the idea. Percy believes that if a student can remove all the media, then they are learning. This is a challenge and does not come easy. Taking the classes not directly related to a major gives more opportunity for a student to learn how to learn. Students must practice and through experience, will ultimately achieve it. The classes that may be deemed unnecessary or pointless, are potentially helping the students on becoming expert learners, and eventually experts in their field.
Secondly, taking multiple classes can lead to failure in some. As a student fails a class, their learning gets weaker, which causes their loss of sovereignty. Students cannot control the number of credits they must take, but the one thing they can control is how they take them. They then regain their power by deciding what they’re gonna do, taking the class to the best of their ability. Walker Percy wrote, “ a sovereignty of the knower—instead of being a consumer of a prepared experience, I am a sovereign wayfarer, a wanderer in the neighborhood of being who stumbles into the garden” (Percy 5). No student is prepared to fail a class, so when one does fail, they have to regain control of their ability to do well in classes. Like a wanderer, no one knows exactly how to bounce back from failure until they do it. Percy wrote that he stumbles into a garden, something beautiful that he did not mean to find. This is how the student will feel once they find their way back into the class, passing on their own terms.
Draft 1 comments on Abigail Johnson’s team
Praise: Great and clear thesis which clearly explains the focus of the essay.
Constructive: More detail in the second paragraph
Use of Percy: Great use but more would be better.
Draft 1 Comments on Juliana Beristain
Praise: Great supporting reasons to solve the problem
Constructive: Explain more on how to solve the problem rather than explaining how it would fix it.
Use of Percy: Great use and analyzation of Percy.
Draft #1
Project 2 Draft
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1B1MuUKObTSu9CMmdoEqKlExy4r_nY0BsT0Fiq6ofYkQ/edit?usp=sharing
Sean Redding
WRT120
November 3rd, 2019
Project #2 Draft
A lot of students arrive to West Chester University dead set on a certain major, or they don’t have a clue on what they want to do in life. With a large selection of classes and gen-eds, many students are able to achieve higher learning in different fields other than their major. With classes such as public speaking and writing, students gain a learning opportunity outside their major that can help them in the real world.With all of the courses WCU has to offer, there is much more information to obtain than just inside the limits of a singular major.
Many majors require a vast knowledge in other subjects or fields in order to completely succeed in said major. For example, if someone were unable to speak publicly as a business major, and were planning on presenting business ideas or running their own business, they would not be as successful as a business major who were able to successfully speak in front of groups of people in order to pitch business ideas. In my opinion, having information in general fields can always aid to specific majors. As stated in the works of Percy, “A student who has the desire to get at a dogfish or a Shakespeare sonnet may have the greatest difficulty in salvaging the creature itself from the educational package in which it is presented” (Percy, pg 4). I believe this quote suggests that it would be hard to truly master a major unless you had succeeded in other areas that aid to said major. Another example of this would be a major in Cultural Anthropology. A majority of this major revolves around field work, and recording said field work. If a student had no strength in writing, they would not be able to accurately record said findings in their fieldwork. In fact, not being able to accurately depict findings through writing is imperative to the major. If one does field work about a foreign culture and inaccurately depicts them in their writings, that culture may be offended, and it would also be inaccurate fieldwork all together.
Another point to be made about students taking classes outside of their major, is that these extra classes help to prepare students for the real world. Classes like public speaking, basic math and writing classes,psychology, and yoga ultimately prepare many students who all have different majors or even just in life. Taking yoga classes as an elective teaches students different methods of stretching and meditation. Taking a psychology class can ultimately help any person understand more about people and their personalities. Classes like these can not only aid people who have already decided their major, but also aids people who are undecided. These classes teach skills that can be useful no matter what major a student may have. As stated by Perry, “Has been appropriated by the symbolic complex which has already been formed in the sightseer’s mind” (Percy, pg. 1). This quote seems to suggest that by being close-minded to a specific major and not taking advantage of the skills learned in the elective or gen-ed classes, they may not be taking advantage of the full college experience.
In conclusion, taking classes that aren’t directly associated with a major ultimately can benefit a student in their own major, and can benefit students throughout life.