Praise: Your thesis is well and you have good points to support your topic.
Constructive: Try to be more detailed in your topic sentences
Percy: You used percy’s ideas well to back up your points.
Category: Weekly Responses
comments on maddie draft
Praise: Your opening is good and hits all the points you need.
Constructive: You can add more to your thesis, talking about percy
percy: your use of quotes from percy support your ideas well.
Peer Review for Maddie Barker
PEER REVIEW 2: maddie barker
Praise:
Makayla – The support for the quotes is very descriptive and well done.
Maura – The connection between West Chester, the problem, the solution, and Percy is strong.
Gwen – The organization is really well done and helps strengthen the argument.
All – The supportive reasoning you used after each quote is super well done and very impressive! Great job!
Constructive:
Makayla – Be sure to stay in the same tense throughout a sentence.
Maura – Watch out for run-on sentences and be sure to capitalize where necessary.
Gwen – Try to use the strongest parts of quotes and work it into sentences.
Percy:
Makayla – Your first quote works really well with the idea you are arguing, but it is a very long sentence that might be able to be a little bit more pinpointed.
Maura – The explanation backing the quote in the second paragraph really supports the quote and connects Percy’s beliefs to your essay.
Gwen – In the fourth paragraph, the connection between Percy’s belief of avoiding the professor’s lecture based teaching really supports your argument that online platforms are a better way to learn.
comments #2 on Rabi Muhammad and Ruth Lohman
neg don’t fall for the trap about the educational packaging if you’re having teachers plan things for the students
Good use on Percy as support from the author
Constructive: good idea be more precise as to how the effective setup and discussion groups would be set up
Constructive: Great intro and transition into the context of your major
too just a little grammar error
good use of Percy in support of the idea
Peer Review On Abby’s team draft
Praise: Your thesis statement is a very good lead up to the rest of your essay.
Constructive: Quotes make an essay a lot stronger, this essay would be much stronger if supporting quotes were included.
Percy: No quotes from Percy are in this to back up your theory, it is very hard to tell this essay relates to Percy or Friere at all without quotes.
Peer Review for Olivia Vearling
- Praise: I really like your idea for a part time job, and how you relate it not only to a student’s future job, but also how it helps them now.
- Negative: I was also thinking about writing about tutoring, but Professor Cream said it is too closely related to the classroom/ student-teacher relationship, so it can’t be used
- Use of Percy: Like Gabe said, you should use Percy’s ideas and quotes to make your arguments stronger and more easily understandable
Peer review draft
Kyle Owens peer review of Maddie Barker
Constructive- Constructive: you have a strong thesis, however I would include some more detail to add length to this introduction.
Use of percy: I would relate the quote back to Percy a bit more to better relate your thesis and Percy.
praise: your topics are very clear and the paper is very well organized. All of the facts and quotes are able to support your claims.
Peer Review for Brandon Zahal’s group
- Praise: I like how you clearly stated the problem, and have multiple problems to talk about
- Negative: I think you need stronger/more specific arguments
- Use of Percy: I don’t know what quotes you’re going to use, but make sure they relate to your topic
Peer review draft 2
Kyle Owens peer review of Rabi
constructive: Possibly add a factual statement to support this claim and to be more persuasive.
Praise: I think this is a great quote to strongly support your claim about working outside the classroom. I would add this quote into the same paragraph.
Use of Percy: When citing Percy I would put the quote before the explanation, and add more detail.
Peer Draft Review for Ethan Stein
Ethan, This is an exceptionally good start! I enjoyed reading what you wrote and wanted it to continue. The sign of a good writer. I especially like what you said: “Humans learn more from their mistakes than from their successes.” Your thesis is good, but from what I observed in your subpoints, I think you could make it better. Beef it up a little and make it stronger. The Percy quotes are perfectly relevant to your subpoints.
Peer Review for Draft- Jacob Heikkinen
Jacob, Your thesis is strong and well written. Your two sub-points well support your Percy quotes. My only suggestion for you is to make sure your next two points are just as strong. If not, it could weaken an already terrific paper. Also, make sure you edit grammatical errors:).
Peer Review 2, Kenzie and Jenna
Positive: Overall your essay is forming well, if you continue to delve deeper into these areas of thought, then incorporate Freire’s writing you should have a decent essay in the end.
Negative: I would try to break your essay up into more than two paragraphs, also MLA format, it can get hard to read. (Fixed the font and double spaced it)
Use of Percy: Great example followed by a clarified explanation, I would delve deeper into this topic before heading into Freire.
Peer Review 2, Olivia Vearling
Positive: Good idea using the class we’re writing this essay on as an example of what should be done rather than what shouldn’t be, it relates to the reader.
Negative: Decent Thesis but try to implement either Percy or Freire, this way it’s understood that the essay will focus on their writings.
Use of Percy: I think you should probably include Percy somewhere in your work, granted this is a draft but it’s beneficial to include his quotations and concepts as a means to have your reader better understand your focal points.
Peer review 2: Isabella Bedore
PEER REVIEW 2:
Praise:
Makayla: I think that your first sentence of your intro is strong and catches your reader’s attention
Maura : the different ways you gave that students can learn the material in a non-traditional way is good
Gwen: You have very strong evidence to back up your points.
Constructive:
Makayla : have a set thesis that points out the main ideas of what the paper is going to be about
Maura: try to find another way to introduce your next topic in your last paragraph instead of saying “ another way to”
Gwen: Work on your transitions from paragraph to paragraph, but other than that it looks good!
Percy:
Makayla: The idea of having the classrooms be more of a student centered style of learning can be connected with Percy because he always says that the teacher shouldnt be the expert and the students should have more of a leadership role in the classroom.
Maura:Your use of Percy in your paragraphs is good and connects to the way he sees how education is and they way that students should be learning
Gwen: The first quote that you picked goes very well with your connection to Percy and supports your first body paragraph.
Draft Comments for Bella Bedore
Praise: I think the beginning of your intro sounds great and is really well-worded. It gives a good background of what your essay topic is about.
Constructive: it looks like ‘facilitated discussions’ is your first method to combatting the problem you posed, and that self-guided labs is a second way. Try including that in the intro as your thesis statement so it really gives a good overview of what it is you’re going to be talking about!
Use of Percy: I think this quote you picked from Percy greatly supports your first point, and you did a good job of explaining what it means in the context of your essay.
Draft Comments for Ava Hill
Praise: I think your intro sounds great! Your thesis gives a clear overview of what your essay is going to talk about, and you incorporated the use of Percy and Freire very nicely.
Constructive: maybe briefly explain what the course EGP 209 is to give more context because I personally don’t know what it is.
Use of Percy: your essay seems to be filled with great quotes from Percy, but this one especially is good because it highlights the point behind prepackaged views.
Peer Review of Olivia Riley’s Draft
Praise: Your writing is very clear, flowing, and organized. You present the ideas of Percy swiftly with the ways taking outside courses promotes student learning.
Constructive: Your examples need more reasoning as to why they are important to student learning.
Percy: The quote you used for paragraph one is easily understood by the reader to further the idea that students should take classes outside their major.
Kira Aves Draft Comments
Kira Aves
Praise: I like how you incorporated the symbolic complex into this paragraph, because this was a key problem in the learners mind according to Percy
Constructive: Maybe your two other points could be internships and experimental learning (For example, observations)
Percy: I like how you backed up what you previously stated about the symbolic complex with this quote from Percy
Draft Comments Jasons Group
David & Jason
Praise: I think that these are good choices to present the ideas of teaching without teaching, all of these are indirect and student based
Constructive: What techniques are you referring to? Very broad. Also how are you going to incorporate Freire, he was not mentioned in your introduction.
Percy: this was a good choice of quote to use considering the topic of the paragraph is to allow students to research for themselves