https://docs.google.com/document/d/1eD0It7VdbWVKThajKI0K89C_7H3MjKZFL7BMqzaxSjw/edit
Category: Weekly Responses
Final Draft
Peer review for John Camperson
Praise: really good essay so far
Constructive: maybe try finding stronger words for descriptions
Percy: quotes work very well
Proposal Review 2
Praise: good thesis, very strong
Constructive: I had this same point and he told me not to use it
Percy: Good quotes to support your ideas, just make sure you analyze them well
Proposal Review 1
Constructive: Focus more on what you aim to prove this seems more like an SOD
Percy: go more in depth with your ideas linked to Percy and differentiate them more, they’re very similar
Praise: good quotes that connect to your ideas just make sure you analyze
Review 1
Praise: I like that you are doing a discussion rather than a traditional essay
Percy: good links to percy, but maybe further analyze them
Constructive: make sure you link to WCU more
Review 1
Percy: I like this quote for your idea but maybe explain it in a sentence.
constructive: further explain this in order to get your point across better
positive: overall really good!! your points are very strong
Long Draft Comments 2
Use of Percy: make sure you mention his writing, but good introducing him right away
Praise: good job linking all of your solutions to West Chester and Percy. Very good and strong points
Constructive: watch out for run on sentences and small grammatical errors
Long Draft Review
Praise: Good job introducing both Percy and Freire in the opening paragraph.
Constructive: watch your tenses and make sure you don’t switch it up
Use of Percy: good quote but you don’t need to introduce his writing again
Jason Riberio and David Heffron Final Project 2
Sabrina Lindsey Draft 2
Pro:You are very clear with your introduction. It gives me a great idea of what the essay will be about
Con: Organization could use some work, have a clear idea and then slightly gets jumbled
Percy: Great quotes, really develop your points well
Peer review #2, Gabe Jasinski
Dana Roeder
Positive: Once again, great way to apply the topic with an example that’s relatively universal to all students, or at the very least feasible to most students, shows correlation.
Negative: Maybe cut back a little on the quoting, also be sure to have the correct format on the final draft.
Use of Percy: Great work on incorporating Percy’s view at the start with your thesis.
Brandon Zahal, Chad Weldon, RJ Walther
Positive: While obvious, it’s good that you’ve mentioned the underlying issue in the first slide rather than mention Percy’s article.
Negative: In general I’d just add a little more to each slide, From how it looks it’s obviously not done but a few more key pieces here and there wouldn’t hurt.
Use of Percy: Wonderful quote to be applying towards the topic of education outside the classroom, hits home the idea that students regard themselves as learners rather than storage spaces for knowledge.
Julia DiGiorgio Peer Review
Positive: I like how you compare/contrast high school and college in the opening part of your writing.
Constructive: I would recommend skimming over your essay and just proof read your sentences, check for spelling and word choice ect.
Percy: The paper has a good amount of ideas related to Percy, I would try and get a little better quotes and elaborate them more.
Jason Riberio Review
positive: You had very good transitions and flow from one point to another in your essay.
Constructive:Try changing your wording around and sentence structure, some parts of the essay get a little bit repetitive.
Percy: Overall the usage of Percy was great, I like how you ended the paper talking about Percy.
Jacob Heikkinen Draft 2 Review
Constructive: I don’t like how you opened up straight off the bat with Percy. Try to have a more gradual introduction.
Percy: try to elaborate on your quotes more instead of leaving them to the end of the paragraphs
Positive: I like how short and sweet this explanation was. I like how you have a very strong argument here.
Review to Jacob Heikkinen Draft #2
Constructive: You should introduce the problem that students are facing at wcu, and connect it with Percy’s ideas.
Praise: I like how do you have Percy’s ideas on the text and I can identify them, but you need some direct explanation from his own text.
Percy: Good use of Percy’s quotes.
Lauren’s Team peer review for Draft 2. Ava Hill and Haley’s Team
Commenting: Donny Lessing, TJ Fitzpatrick, Nick Gamba
Praise: I think your essay is very good, it has references, it explains the topic, and it is supported.
Criticism: I would try to explain your examples more to help thoroughly understand it.
Percy: I think your references are good but I would add more references to help support your claim.
Review to Kyle Owens Draft #2
Praise: I like how did you explain the problem to introduce it to your project.
Percy: I believe that this is the main idea and propose from both of the authors.
Constructive: I think that you should add some direct support from the text to support your ideas.
Comments to Haley Myers
Praise: I think the thesis clearly states what you are going to be talking about. The ideas are very good as well.
Constructive: I think there are a few run on sentences that could be broken down or shortened.
Percy: You have clear connections to Percy throughout your essay that flow good with your ideas.