Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Writing & Blogs – Page 10 – WRT120 F2019 Prof Randall Cream

PEER REVEIW LONG DRAFT:Nik Passias

Praise:

Makayla: Your intro is strong and you have a lot of good points for learning outside the classroom 

Maura: Your idea of study groups is really good 

Gwen: Your Paragraph on peer tutoring and the teacher not always staying on topic is good because this happens in real life. 

Constructive:

Makayla: Try to relate the topic to West Chester more in your intro

Maura: You should add more to your second paragraph it ends fast 

Gwen: Try to change your wording for the beginning of the paragraphs instead of saying “another way”  

Percy:

Makayla: your use of percy for the first reason relates well to your idea and you interpreted it well

Maura: The use of percy in the second paragraph relates well to the way learning can happen outside the classroom and West Chetser

Gwen: The quote used for the peer tutoring relates well to the way teachers teach and the way that students have to learn in college 

PEER REVIEW LONG DRAFT: Olivia Vearling

Praise:

Makayla: The second and third paragraphs are super in depth and well understood by a reader.

Maura: The first body paragraph is super strong and really offers a lot to the rest of the essay.

Gwen: You have a super good connection between WCU and your claim consistently throughout the essay.

Constructive:

Makayla: Try to include Percy in your introduction.

Maura: It might be beneficial to try to add some more to the intro about the specifics of your claim.

Gwen: Maybe try to add more about Percy to the last paragraph and include some quotes.

Percy:

Makayla: The connection to Percy in the third paragraph really helps connect the quote to your claim.

Maura: Add some more about Percy, especially quotes, to strengthen to connection to Percy.

Gwen: This is good support to your quote and claim but it’s difficult to connect to Percy with just one mention of him.

Amanda Jiang & Leah Schreffler – Long draft peer review

Your  paper is clear and easy to understand. I like what you say: Having students teach other students allows for a better connection because there is no higher authority over the students. This is an excellent point. 

In your thesis, you mentioned a class that is not good, I wonder if you should contrast it with a class that is doing it better. You can play around with that a bit to see if it strengthens your thesis. 

Revised Draft Comments: Meghan Kidd/ Sam Pawluczyk

Constructive: Considering the topic is Teaching without Teaching, your use of lecturing is still driven from the educator and does not exactly achieve this goal of teaching without teaching due to the fact that the teacher would still be giving the students a prepackaged concept.

Percy: Make sure you add a quote from Percy (or Freire) to support what you are saying. How does Percy distinguish that students should be teaching?

Praise: I believe discussions achieve the idea of teaching without teaching, Percy believes that students should avoid the educators presentation and Freire believes that students should fight for their emancipation and Percy believes students must fight for their sovereignty

Revised Draft Comment John Camperson

Constructive: Try to find another word instead of using “kind of.” For example instead say, In Walker Percy’s work of “The Loss of the Creature,” he explains that in order to increase learning one must put themselves in someone else shoes. Kind of sounds unsure.

Praise: I really like this sub point, study groups is a wonderful way for students to experience transformative learning outside the classroom.

Percy: I think that there may be another quote from Percy that can connect to students daily reflection. I believe this quote has more to do with the educator than the students planning their days out.

Kenzie and Jenna’s final copy

At West Chester University classes are lecture-based. Lecture-based learning is proven ineffective by both Percy and Freire. Both similarly state that people cannot learn by being given the information, they have to make the information has meaning to them in order to learn. Both Percy and Freire acknowledge the role of a teacher in education and caution the fault in lecture-based learning. Percy and Freire both prove that this role needs to be improved for the learner to learn. West Chester University can accomplish this goal by embracing formative assessment, inquiry-based learning, project-based projects, and discussion group-based learning into its curriculum.

One way to improve learning at West Chester University is to implement formative assessment into the classroom. In the formative assessment structure, teachers monitor students by providing ongoing feedback. The goal of formative assessment is to help students understand their strengths and weaknesses. One way to use formative assessment is to provide students with tests that they can take multiple times to show them what they need to study or not. By allowing students to be able to take tests multiple times the student decides the pace they go. This allows students that need more help with topics more time without moving ahead when they are not ready. This also allows students that have already learned the information, to pass through it quickly so they do not have to relearn information they already know. This disconnect between students and the pace of a class is something that formative assessment in a classroom can stop. In this structure, the assessment goes beyond grading by examining patterns through quizzes and using those patterns to improve their education. Percy proves this would be an effective way of learning by saying, “A student who has the desire to get a dogfish or a Shakespeare sonnet may have the greatest difficulty in salvaging the creature itself from the educational package in which is presented” (Percy 4). This shows that a student cannot learn from a direct presentation. It allows the student to follow their own path by taking assessments to learn what they need to. Freire also proves this would be an effective way of learning by saying, “It is not surprising that the banking concept of education regards men as adaptable, manageable beings. The more students work at storing the deposits entrusted to them, the less they develop the critical consciousness which would result from their intervention in the world as transformers of that world” (Freire, 2). This shows if a student does not ignore the direct presentation they would not learn. By avoiding the direct presentation of the object, allows the student to gain sovereignty and to take the beaten path to further their education.

One form of teaching that can better improve learning for West Chester students is inquiry-based learning. This is where the student drives the class and takes over. This is done by the student who is given a problem or scenario, and the student completes this task by asking questions and figuring the problem out for themselves with no previous lecture from the teacher. This form of teaching eliminates students having to memorize topics that mean nothing to them. Instead, students learn by solving problems and building knowledge through exploration and experience. Students can only learn by making connections to the object that they are trying to learn about. Freire proves this to be an effective form of learning by saying “Problem-posing education affirms men and women as beings in the process of becoming—as unfinished, uncompleted beings in and with a likewise unfinished reality” (Freire, 6). This shows that in the beginning, people do not know the answer to the question. So, they must find the answer for themselves to learn. Percy also finds inquiry-based learning to be true. He stated that “The educator whose business it is to teach students biology or poetry is unaware of a whole ensemble of relations which exist between the student and the dogfish and between the student and the Shakespeare sonnet”(Percy, 4). This demonstrates the need for the student to learn without the professor. Since the professor cannot see the connection between the individual student and the topic they are learning, the student must learn the information for themselves. The student also needs to find their connection to the topic to understand the true answer to the problem. 

Another way to better learning at West Chester University is to invoke project-based learning into the education system. When a student uses project-based learning they are given a task to complete without getting any information on the subject beforehand similarly to inquiry-based model. The student continues doing the project and has multiple trials and errors before they come to the answer they were looking for. When the student fails, they must learn from this failure to complete the task. By the student continuing working on the project they are learning more about the object then they would in a lecture-based classroom. The students must apply their current knowledge to apply it to a new task. Percy supports this idea by stating “In truth, the biography of scientists and poets is usually the story of the discovery of the indirect approach, the circumvention of the educator’s presentation-the young man who was sent to the Technikum and on his way fell into the habit of loitering in the book stores and reading poetry; or the young man dutifully attending law school who on the way became curious about the comings and goings of ants” (Percy, 5). Percy is saying that the young man who fell into learning the subjects learned more than the students who are majoring in the topics. By saying that Percy is supporting the idea that students learn by trial and error just as project-based learning recommends. Freire also supports the idea for the need of project-based learning by stating “In problem-posing education, people develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world with which and in which they find themselves; they come to see the world not as a static reality, but as a reality in process, in transformation.” (Freire, 5). By saying this Freire is saying students can only learn when the information comes to their own reality. Project-based learning supports this idea because students must keep doing the project for themselves without any previous knowledge of the topic. The student must relate the project to themselves to learn. 

         Lastly, discussion groups are a better way to implement teaching at West Chester University. In this method, everybody takes part in the discussion, therefore thinking and expressing their own thoughts. The role of the teacher in this method is nonexistent, the students have full control of how the discussion will go. In this, students will present the topic and express their own thoughts then other students will chime in and express their own opinions. The students start learning by talking to other students and bouncing ideas back and forth. Freire proves this would be an effective way of learning by saying,  “In problem-posing education, people develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world with which and in which they find themselves; they come to see the world not as a static reality, but as a reality in process, in transformation.” (Freire, 5). By allowing students to create their own opinions about the topic is allowing them to connect it to their world. Which in the mind of Freire is how learning takes place. Percy also proves this to be an effective way of learning by saying, “Poetry students should find dogfishes on their desks and biology students should find Shakespearean sonnets on their direction boards.” (Percy, 4). This would allow students to be able to discuss with each other to learn about another topic. Allowing students to discuss their opinions resulting in students learning from communicating.         Percy and Freire both state in their writings that the role of a teacher is needed in the education process. The role of the teacher can be improved by implementing formative assessment, inquiry-based learning, project-based projects, and discussion groups into West Chester’s curriculum. These class structures can better the student’s overall academic experience. The student will be able to learn topics and retain the information better than they would in a lecture-based classroom.

Peer review Draft 2

Johnson, Nolan, Desario

Praise: Good well developed ideas.
Constructive: Few grammatical errors, a quote thrown in to the second to last paragraph is not cited nor makes sense there. Restate your thesis in your conclusion not word for word.
Percy: Good use of Percy throughout.

Peer-review draft 2

Abigail Johnson, Nicholas Nolan, Isabella DeSario

Percy: Great use of Percy to support your ideas. You guys did a good job of relating the quote to your idea

Constructive: The second to last paragraph is awkward and refers to Percys quote which is not given

Praise: Overall good ideas and you guys did a good job explaining what you think is the benefits of each idea and how to relate that to Percy

Peer review

Kyle Owens review of Sabrina Lindey

Praise: introduction paragraph is very well organized and does the job of relaying to the reader what will be discussed in following paragraphs.

use of Percy: I like how you introduced your idea of the package then shared the Percy quote. it helped me to better understand it.

constructive: the whole entire paper should be summed up in this paragraph. Restate the main ideas of the paper.

peer review

Kyle Owens Haley Myers review

praise: good introduction of Percy, be sure to introduce Friere as well if needed.

Use of Percy: this quote is very fitting for your paper. good choice and use of Percy.

Constructive: try to work on developing longer transition sentences to more easily change topics.

Peer Review – Draft 2 – Sean Redding

Constructive: 

  • You addressed the problem in your intro; however, you need to address the opportunities or solutions that the community invests in allowing students to further their studies.  The sentence starting with ” as a criminal justice major” is your thesis and should be your first sentence of the intro and then go into the details you talked about. Next explain how the community can further studies in the 4 topics you will talk about. 
  • I would say, “I believe Freire is suggesting that…”

Praise:

  • Your ideas to promote community interaction to further one’s studies provide clear evidence of how the community will help one in the future work force. I really like how you focused on Criminal Justice and see the community as the biggest victim to it. 

Percy:

  • You explain Percy’s quotes very clearly. I think you should find different ways to transition into the Percy quotes and begin the analysis of the quote differently instead of saying ” I believe”
css.php