Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Responses – Page 10 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Revised Draft Comment John Camperson

Constructive: Try to find another word instead of using “kind of.” For example instead say, In Walker Percy’s work of “The Loss of the Creature,” he explains that in order to increase learning one must put themselves in someone else shoes. Kind of sounds unsure.

Praise: I really like this sub point, study groups is a wonderful way for students to experience transformative learning outside the classroom.

Percy: I think that there may be another quote from Percy that can connect to students daily reflection. I believe this quote has more to do with the educator than the students planning their days out.

Kenzie and Jenna’s final copy

At West Chester University classes are lecture-based. Lecture-based learning is proven ineffective by both Percy and Freire. Both similarly state that people cannot learn by being given the information, they have to make the information has meaning to them in order to learn. Both Percy and Freire acknowledge the role of a teacher in education and caution the fault in lecture-based learning. Percy and Freire both prove that this role needs to be improved for the learner to learn. West Chester University can accomplish this goal by embracing formative assessment, inquiry-based learning, project-based projects, and discussion group-based learning into its curriculum.

One way to improve learning at West Chester University is to implement formative assessment into the classroom. In the formative assessment structure, teachers monitor students by providing ongoing feedback. The goal of formative assessment is to help students understand their strengths and weaknesses. One way to use formative assessment is to provide students with tests that they can take multiple times to show them what they need to study or not. By allowing students to be able to take tests multiple times the student decides the pace they go. This allows students that need more help with topics more time without moving ahead when they are not ready. This also allows students that have already learned the information, to pass through it quickly so they do not have to relearn information they already know. This disconnect between students and the pace of a class is something that formative assessment in a classroom can stop. In this structure, the assessment goes beyond grading by examining patterns through quizzes and using those patterns to improve their education. Percy proves this would be an effective way of learning by saying, “A student who has the desire to get a dogfish or a Shakespeare sonnet may have the greatest difficulty in salvaging the creature itself from the educational package in which is presented” (Percy 4). This shows that a student cannot learn from a direct presentation. It allows the student to follow their own path by taking assessments to learn what they need to. Freire also proves this would be an effective way of learning by saying, “It is not surprising that the banking concept of education regards men as adaptable, manageable beings. The more students work at storing the deposits entrusted to them, the less they develop the critical consciousness which would result from their intervention in the world as transformers of that world” (Freire, 2). This shows if a student does not ignore the direct presentation they would not learn. By avoiding the direct presentation of the object, allows the student to gain sovereignty and to take the beaten path to further their education.

One form of teaching that can better improve learning for West Chester students is inquiry-based learning. This is where the student drives the class and takes over. This is done by the student who is given a problem or scenario, and the student completes this task by asking questions and figuring the problem out for themselves with no previous lecture from the teacher. This form of teaching eliminates students having to memorize topics that mean nothing to them. Instead, students learn by solving problems and building knowledge through exploration and experience. Students can only learn by making connections to the object that they are trying to learn about. Freire proves this to be an effective form of learning by saying “Problem-posing education affirms men and women as beings in the process of becoming—as unfinished, uncompleted beings in and with a likewise unfinished reality” (Freire, 6). This shows that in the beginning, people do not know the answer to the question. So, they must find the answer for themselves to learn. Percy also finds inquiry-based learning to be true. He stated that “The educator whose business it is to teach students biology or poetry is unaware of a whole ensemble of relations which exist between the student and the dogfish and between the student and the Shakespeare sonnet”(Percy, 4). This demonstrates the need for the student to learn without the professor. Since the professor cannot see the connection between the individual student and the topic they are learning, the student must learn the information for themselves. The student also needs to find their connection to the topic to understand the true answer to the problem. 

Another way to better learning at West Chester University is to invoke project-based learning into the education system. When a student uses project-based learning they are given a task to complete without getting any information on the subject beforehand similarly to inquiry-based model. The student continues doing the project and has multiple trials and errors before they come to the answer they were looking for. When the student fails, they must learn from this failure to complete the task. By the student continuing working on the project they are learning more about the object then they would in a lecture-based classroom. The students must apply their current knowledge to apply it to a new task. Percy supports this idea by stating “In truth, the biography of scientists and poets is usually the story of the discovery of the indirect approach, the circumvention of the educator’s presentation-the young man who was sent to the Technikum and on his way fell into the habit of loitering in the book stores and reading poetry; or the young man dutifully attending law school who on the way became curious about the comings and goings of ants” (Percy, 5). Percy is saying that the young man who fell into learning the subjects learned more than the students who are majoring in the topics. By saying that Percy is supporting the idea that students learn by trial and error just as project-based learning recommends. Freire also supports the idea for the need of project-based learning by stating “In problem-posing education, people develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world with which and in which they find themselves; they come to see the world not as a static reality, but as a reality in process, in transformation.” (Freire, 5). By saying this Freire is saying students can only learn when the information comes to their own reality. Project-based learning supports this idea because students must keep doing the project for themselves without any previous knowledge of the topic. The student must relate the project to themselves to learn. 

         Lastly, discussion groups are a better way to implement teaching at West Chester University. In this method, everybody takes part in the discussion, therefore thinking and expressing their own thoughts. The role of the teacher in this method is nonexistent, the students have full control of how the discussion will go. In this, students will present the topic and express their own thoughts then other students will chime in and express their own opinions. The students start learning by talking to other students and bouncing ideas back and forth. Freire proves this would be an effective way of learning by saying,  “In problem-posing education, people develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world with which and in which they find themselves; they come to see the world not as a static reality, but as a reality in process, in transformation.” (Freire, 5). By allowing students to create their own opinions about the topic is allowing them to connect it to their world. Which in the mind of Freire is how learning takes place. Percy also proves this to be an effective way of learning by saying, “Poetry students should find dogfishes on their desks and biology students should find Shakespearean sonnets on their direction boards.” (Percy, 4). This would allow students to be able to discuss with each other to learn about another topic. Allowing students to discuss their opinions resulting in students learning from communicating.         Percy and Freire both state in their writings that the role of a teacher is needed in the education process. The role of the teacher can be improved by implementing formative assessment, inquiry-based learning, project-based projects, and discussion groups into West Chester’s curriculum. These class structures can better the student’s overall academic experience. The student will be able to learn topics and retain the information better than they would in a lecture-based classroom.

Peer review Draft 2

Johnson, Nolan, Desario

Praise: Good well developed ideas.
Constructive: Few grammatical errors, a quote thrown in to the second to last paragraph is not cited nor makes sense there. Restate your thesis in your conclusion not word for word.
Percy: Good use of Percy throughout.

Peer-review draft 2

Abigail Johnson, Nicholas Nolan, Isabella DeSario

Percy: Great use of Percy to support your ideas. You guys did a good job of relating the quote to your idea

Constructive: The second to last paragraph is awkward and refers to Percys quote which is not given

Praise: Overall good ideas and you guys did a good job explaining what you think is the benefits of each idea and how to relate that to Percy

Peer review

Kyle Owens review of Sabrina Lindey

Praise: introduction paragraph is very well organized and does the job of relaying to the reader what will be discussed in following paragraphs.

use of Percy: I like how you introduced your idea of the package then shared the Percy quote. it helped me to better understand it.

constructive: the whole entire paper should be summed up in this paragraph. Restate the main ideas of the paper.

peer review

Kyle Owens Haley Myers review

praise: good introduction of Percy, be sure to introduce Friere as well if needed.

Use of Percy: this quote is very fitting for your paper. good choice and use of Percy.

Constructive: try to work on developing longer transition sentences to more easily change topics.

Peer Review – Draft 2 – Sean Redding

Constructive: 

  • You addressed the problem in your intro; however, you need to address the opportunities or solutions that the community invests in allowing students to further their studies.  The sentence starting with ” as a criminal justice major” is your thesis and should be your first sentence of the intro and then go into the details you talked about. Next explain how the community can further studies in the 4 topics you will talk about. 
  • I would say, “I believe Freire is suggesting that…”

Praise:

  • Your ideas to promote community interaction to further one’s studies provide clear evidence of how the community will help one in the future work force. I really like how you focused on Criminal Justice and see the community as the biggest victim to it. 

Percy:

  • You explain Percy’s quotes very clearly. I think you should find different ways to transition into the Percy quotes and begin the analysis of the quote differently instead of saying ” I believe”

Peer Review – Draft 2 – Makayla’s Team

Constructive: 

  • I think you guys have a pretty good intro. I think it can be expanded more. You use “in” a lot to start sentences, maybe vary it. For the one sentence you can be like “High school students could spend extra hours analyzing the content learned from class; yet, in a college setting, students are expected to study extra hours to excel in their studies.”
  • I would get rid of ” the first way that a” and Just start and say “students can get involved…by joining clubs”
  • replace says with “acknowledges that,”
  • Instead of saying professional in second body, I would say “more prepared for the workforce”

Praise:

  • I really like the quote you used and your explanation. You make it very clear to the reader.
  • very good explanation of the quote in second body. It was very clear and concise.  

Percy:

  • All your quotes clearly emphasize your topic in the ways you plan to solve the problem of student involvement outside of the classroom. I would just transition into your first two quotes a little better than saying “Percy says”

Draft 2: Project 2 Topic 4

https://docs.google.com/document/d/17eDXSViJqy-IvysGGLNvkM_Zmcvm6SrVQyvCBr1qwI0/edit

Amanda Jiang & Leah Schreffler

Dr. Randall Cream

Writing 120

3 November 2019

Good quality teaching involves interaction and socialization between students. A good professor takes time to understand the student’s background and needs. The teacher builds a relationship with the student. In Walker Percy’s “The Loss of the Creature” and Paulo Freire’s “The Banking Concept of Education”, they address the current issue that is affecting the education system. Freire explains the problem of the banking concept of education. This means that teachers feed information to students and they absorb it like robots. This way of education does not teach students. Percy talks about educational content as a “package” and explains how students do not gain or learn anything by this way of teaching. West Chester University has adapted these ways of teaching. Both authors talk about how students do not learn from the teacher, they learn from each other. Creating a learning environment where students are not taught by the teacher allows for a different way of learning. One class that West Chester offers is HEA 110 Transcultural health, a class that teachers teach students as passive objects. This class is a prime example of how a class should not be taught according to Percy’s and Freire’s ideas. We believe good teaching can happen at West Chester through trial and error, observation, and students teaching students.

A popular saying that many are familiar with is you learn from your mistakes. Mistakes are inevitable but after multiple mistakes, you will eventually find your solution. This is called trial and error.  Trial and error creates new pathways of learning for students. The trial is observation of different methods to find a solution. If it does not then a new method is to be tested until a solution is reached. Trial and error is used in problem solving.  In HEA 110, trial and error can be used when the teacher assigns research topics on cultural differences. Making students work in groups to identify each culture group problems and their differences in each culture. This is a new way of learning that will benefit the students. 

One way to implement good teaching at WCU would be for teachers to ask students to teach themselves through observation. Activities, where students observe information outside of the classroom, allows for comprehension and an advanced way of learning instead of being fed information. By doing observation activities, students are open to new creativity and opportunities that are provided. A quote from Percy states, “…that they have in common the stratagem of avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned and restoring access to sonnet and dogfish as beings to be known, reasserting the sovereignty of knower over known” (Percy 5). Percy explains that the only way a student can learn is by avoiding the teacher’s way of teaching. When students are assigned readings or video assignments, they do not learn as much compared to going somewhere and observing. Students only focused on watching videos and answering given questions rather than understanding the true concepts. Learning outside the four walls of the classroom can significantly improve a student’s academic and developing environmental awareness. By assigning observation assignments beyond the classroom allows students to think outside of the box. This allows students to take the chance to explore and expand their critical thinking. Students can not learn from the teacher and have to discover other ways of learning. 

A new way of changing the way students learn is by having the teacher creates activities that will make students teach students the information. College is all about training students to be future leaders and for this to happen, students have to recognize that they have a voice and an opinion. Speaking for yourself is a hard thing to do and learn. Having interaction in the classroom and in the criteria of the course will allow students to learn to become involved in the class. Students take information from other students and begin to understand different views of things. Seeing the bigger picture of the outside world creates an opportunity for students to seek the moment, creating a new way of learning. “No, but it means that the student should know what a fight he has on his hands to rescue the specimen from the educational package. The educator is only partly to blame. For there is nothing the educator can do to provide for this need of the student. Everything the educator does only succeeds in becoming, for the student, part of the educational package” (Percy 5). Percy is saying that the students have to create their own ways of learning because the teacher is not there to provide the students what they need. Students teaching students is not the traditional way of learning. The problem with traditional teaching was that teachers feeding students the information and they absorb it. Having students teach other students allows for a better connection because there is no higher authority over the students. They are all equal to each other and because of this equality, they will listen to each other. Having this change helps students to focus and begin to learn a different way. 

Project two long draft

The American education system is…not the best in the world, it’s still stuck in the Industrial Age. The structures of education are one of the pillars of a healthy society, as the way a society views education and engages with it on an institutional level will determine the kind of citizenry it has. At W.C.U the school has worked to modernize not only in technology but with procedures and making a shift from lecture focused classes to more interactive methods. Working towards improving education as to be in line with Paulo Freire and Walker Percy’s philosophy about teaching without teaching. In pursuit of the goal of a more egalitarian form of teaching, I propose student led labs, for teachers to better emulate the maieutic virtue by facilitating group discussion, having presentations/seminars led by students, and the removal of tests in place of experience based projects and simulations as well as reflective papers on the topics covered.  

Applying these ideas to say a comparative politics class; let us say Latin Amderican Culture and Politics; for the sake of context would go as follows :Student led labs, as in the dogfish is splayed upon a table and the students go ahead and work with little more than their tools and an objective to learn. Perhaps an exercise on a topic of interest in relation to the class. Percy said that “He(consumer) carves his initials as a last desperate measure to escape his ghostly role as a consumer.” So the labs in which students find their own topics which will then be used as a base for their presentations will allow the students to reclaim their intellectual sovereignty. The labs offer practical skill learning for research data collection and team work. By students working to create something they learn. When students then present on the topic of the labs and what they found, sharing what they discovered through the fruits of their pursuit of learning. Removing the banking approach from the institution we learn by removing the object from the educational package by which the information is wrapped in. As having no instruction equalizes the dynamic of learning therefore making it not an “exercise in domination” but an exchange of information. 

The role of the teacher; they do play a part in this ; is to be the midwife the facilitator that is there highest role as anything more will just be part of the educational package. In practice that would include things like asking questions which propose problems like “What could this indicator suggest? What do these factors point to?” etc..  Therefore allowing the proliferation of thought. The simulation and experience based projects would include having students go out in the field and perform the qualitative/quantitative data collection that will be routine in the field of political science. “…English major who began poking around in a dogfish with a bobby pin would learn more in thirty minutes than a biology major in a whole semester;” Experience is the best teacher after all.

 Leading into my next educational experiment is the idea to have trips to allow students to get hands on experience in the execution of political experiments. Given the nature of social science the students would conduct mock surveys in the surrounding areas and perform cold calling to people, this would be especially useful during the fall semester when election day is held. The surveys serve the dual purpose of getting practical skills for the student such as communication, unbiased question formulation, and data collection. Supporting these ideas Percy Walker said “The measures taken are measures appropriate to the consumer: the expert and the planner know and plan but the consumer needs and experiences.” to break down the divide between “layman”and “expert” Walker Percy praises the value of experience in a technical society. My labs would allow the consumer to take his fill of the knowledge he is deprived of by being passively fed information.

As for my final proposal : reflective papers, about three times per semester the first at the beginning, the second at the halfway point, and thirdly at the end of the semester.  The first one would be worded something like “what do you wish to gain from this course?” By giving the student an active objective and goal for his class the student metaphorically carved his initials in the tree trunk or stone he regains his sovereignty and ceases to be simply a consumer. During the middle of the semester the question would be how the student feels his desired goals are being handled and reignites the class as an active part of the student’s cognition as per Paulo Freire “A deepened consciousness of their situation leads people to apprehend that situation as a historical reality susceptible of transformation.” and this makes them an active participant in their education. Finally at the end of the semester the final reflective paper will allow the student to do much the same as the second and will ask what changes they would make to the course and what the student could have done to make sure all his goals are met in the case they were not all met. This will allow the course to be constantly tweaked to better serve future students and

In conclusion education in the 21st century is a changing entity, we’re doing new things with it and trying to adapt it to an ever changing world and taking old ideas from Freire and Walker turning it from a system of oppression and deprivation to one of intellectual autonomy and active growth. In the modern age we cannot still be using Industrial Age methods the world is full of young minds hungry to learn and go out and be transformers and the skills they need to be successful whether in political science or any discipline is contingent on our system here at W.C.U.

css.php