Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Responses – Page 11 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Final Draft Sean Redding

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1B1MuUKObTSu9CMmdoEqKlExy4r_nY0BsT0Fiq6ofYkQ/edit?usp=sharing

Sean Redding 

Randall Cream

WRT120

November 7th, 2019 

                                                         Final Draft 

         No matter where you reside, the criminal justice system is a prominent feature in each and every community in the United States. There are a vast amount of job opportunities in this field, from police officers, judges, and probation officers to FBI agents, blood spatter analysis, and criminal behavioral analysis, criminal justice jobs are a key component to any working society. Each community has different needs depending on its location. For example, the city of Philadelphia may have a higher crime rate than a small rural town like west chester, and may need more officers equipped for this type of action. As a criminal justice major, it’s hard to choose just one field to go into, and even harder to obtain all of the skills needed to go into the criminal justice fields. Luckily, our community has many opportunities for interactions that can help with this specific major.

         As stated by Freire, “One cannot expect positive results from an educational or political action program which fails to respect the particular view of the world held by the people. Such a program constitutes cultural invasion, good intentions notwithstanding.” (Freire, Ch.3). I believe that this quote is suggesting that one cannot expect to excel in a certain field if they only focus on the core requirements of the major, but will succeed if they are familiar with other elements in the major.  Specifying this concept to a criminal justice major, something like a ride-along, or internship specific to a criminal justice student’s field of interest would be beneficial to their overall goal. By doing an internship, students are able to be placed in an environment similar to the real world experiences outside of college. Internships would be a preparation for life outside of college, especially when it comes to criminal justice majors. Being prepared in the criminal justice field is important, as many jobs in this field require a vast knowledge of the job and subject before entering. 

         Another concept that relates to knowledge outside of a specific major comes from Walker Percy’s theories and works on education. Percy says “A student who has the desire to get a dogfish or a Shakespeare sonnet may have the greatest difficulty in salvaging the creature itself from the educational package in which it is presented” (Percy, pg.4). I believe Percy was stating that a student who is strictly restrained to the limits inside one specific major may have the most difficulty excelling in the major. For a criminal justice major, there are many very simple ways to explore and to get in touch with the community in order to benefit in their majors. One way could be simply to stay updated on criminal justice related news in the community. A student could learn a large amount about what a criminal justice job would be like in a specific community by familiarizing themselves with the typical happenings of the community itself. By learning and getting familiar with the typical issues and crimes in a certain area, students can prepare for what they would be dealing with after graduating and entering the criminal justice fields. If a student were looking to become a police officer in Philadelphia, reading Philly’s local news and seeing about the many on-foot chases officers in Philadelphia have to partake in may lead this student to conclude that they must work on being physically fit for that specific job. This would then put them ahead of a student who did not have this knowledge and had the same goals. 

         One way criminal justice students can learn outside the classroom is with “ride-alongs” with the local police department. A ride along is when a police officer takes a citizen on a shift where they can sit in the passenger seat to see what like on an average shift. Students in CRJ that want to go into the police force can request to do this with local police departments within the community. Doing this the students can get a taste of what it is like to be on the force and see what police officers actually do on shifts.  Freire stated, “The solution is not to integrate them into the structure of oppression, but to transform that structure so that they can become “beings for themselves” (Freire page 2). In this quote Freire talks about how education can cause oppression, but being out in the field with police officers can help introduce students to real world situations to learn on their own.

         In conclusion, criminal justice majors have many hidden advantages in society, as they are able to acquire skills and excel in their fields just by examining their community. It is more important than ever for students to realize the importance of research and internships, as they can gain a vast amount of knowledge by participating in said activities. 

Writing Project 2- Draft 2

Ruthie Lohmann

Dr. Randall Cream

Writing 120

10 November 2019

Writing Project 2 – Teaching without Teaching -Draft #2

There have been millions of teachers throughout history. Some should never have had the honor of that title and most have been long forgotten.  Others made such an indelible mark on their students that their names are still remembered today. So what made these unforgettable educators so remarkable? In reading Paulo Freire’s “The Banking Concept of Education“ and Walker Percy’s “The Loss of the Creature“ I came to understand what teaching should not be and learned through their avoidance of direct writing, what a good teaching ought to be. So what should good teaching be at West Chester University? According to Freire and Percy, good teaching allows for students to learn through ‘communication,’ good teachers are ‘partners’ with the student in the learning process,  good teaching ‘avoids pre-packaged direct presentation,’  and good teaching gives space for the student to ‘struggle for himself,’ though ‘inquiry’ as they learn at a collegiate level. These are all incredible thoughts on paper, but how can a teacher implement these ideas in the classroom? I have four ideas which can make this kind of teaching possible. Teachers should have discussion based classrooms instead of lecture based. Teachers should become partners with student by giving feedback on students homework assignments first and then, if necessary, give a letter grade. Teachers should teach indirectly and not directly by using living books written by experts who are passionate about the topic. Teachers need to recognize that students need to be given the chance to wrestle though material for themselves in order for them to take ownership in their learning- teachers can allow for this by the way they have students write papers and give oral presentation. This kind of teaching is what separates a mediocre and ineffective teacher to one who makes an ineffaceable mark on the lives of their students, and in turn, these students can leave their distinctive mark on the world.

Teachers should have discussion based classrooms instead of lecturing students on subject matter. As the saying goes, and I am not sure who says it, but, the one who teachers is really the one who learns. If we know this to be true, why do we still insist on lecture based teaching? Recently, I experienced two instances in my classes at West Chester that reinforced why dialogue among students and teacher is so important and effective. My Anthropology class began with a lecture and ended with a discussion. As soon as the lecture morphed into a conversation, a palpable shift took place in the room. Almost everyone became relaxed. Laptops and phones were ignored for a few moments in time. Questions were being thrown around the room. The teacher sat on the desk in the most relaxed manner. At the end of class he made a comment about how every class should be like this and that most of his classes the students just blankly stare at him as he talks. He, I would say, is an incredible lecturer. If anyone could hold the students attention, it would be him. His content is interesting, his presentation is engaging, and he clearly is passionate about what he is talking about. But even with all that, it wasn’t until converstlan happened that both teacher and students came to life. 

Freire says, “Yet only through communication can human life hold meaning…a teacher can not think for the student, nor can she impose her thoughts on them. Authentic thinking…does not take place in ivory tower isolation, but only in communication.” Teachers can shift their lecturing by creating a more dialogue friendly seating arrangement. Desks should be placed in a circle with the teachers sitting at a desk with the students. Instead of talking at the students, take turns reading a section of the class material out loud and pose a question for discussion. Sometimes students need help in getting comfortable first, that is when the teacher can break the ice with a student relevant question. The second time I witnessed this obvious shift was in my linguistic class. The students and I were talking in the lobby while we waited for the one class to end. One of the students mentioned how she needs to write an eight page paper on if college education should be free. She expressed that she had no clue what she was going to say. We all got into a lively discussion about this. We did not realize that the other class was finished and our teacher had to come out and get us. He became engaged in the conversation and we spent the first 10-15 minutes of class in dialogue about this topic. It was incredible. When we switched back to linguistics, everyone was more relaxed and at ease. And it led to a productive class. There is something about personally connecting with the students and the teacher that opens the path to deep cognitive leaning, especially when personal stories are shared and when the teacher takes an interest in the affairs of the students. 

(Work on this!)Teachers should do away with given grades before feedback. Unfortunately, grades are necessary in tracking who is learning what – but this leads to so many problems for the student. They become overly concerned with what their letter grade is. They are not learning for themselves but for the grade. Teachers first need to stop this unhealthy obsession with grades and concentrate on helping the students learn for themselves. How do teachers evaluate progress in a more holistic manner though? Give feedback first on any given assignment- then, if necessary, give a letter grade. That might look like meeting with each student to talk through the areas they need to develop. That might mean testing the students knowledge in different ways- through oral presentations, through essays on the material, and even through class discussion. Education is more about becoming. Percy says, “The highest role of the educator is the maieutic role of socrates: to help the student come to himself not as a consumer of experience but as a sovereign individual.” The goal then of the teacher is not that they successful transfer their knowledge to the student so that they can take a test and get a good grade. The goal of the educator is that the student learns the material for himself in order to take ownership and invest in his education for what it is and not for what they can get on a piece of paper.

Teachers should teach indirectly and not directly by using living books written by experts who are passionate about the topic. Freire say, “Verbalistic lessons, reading requirements, the methods for evaluating “knowledge,” the distance between the teacher and the taught, the criteria for promotion: everything in a ready-to-wear approach serves to obviate thinking.” That last thing teachers should want to do in their classroom is create automatons. Teachers want to create critical thinkers who will become future leaders one day. There are three ways this can be accomplished.  An educator should read living books in class which are written by experts who are passionate about the topic.They should then have students write personal reflections on the reading. As the teacher steps back and reads a well written books, it allows the content of the book to engage with the student in an indirect way. Teachers should read a longer passage, pause, and allow the students to turn to a classmate and narrate what they just heard. This puts the learning into the hands of the student while they reflect on what they just heard. Secondly, teachers should have the students give an oral presentation on their reflections of the books they read. After the presentation, there should be an opportunity for questions, disagreements, thoughts, and a time student can share their opinion on the oral presentation.  Lastly, teachers should assign topic relevant books for homework and have the students write a personal essay on what they learned from the book and how they felt about it, instead of giving the students a direct assignment which looks for specific answers. This allows them discover for themselves. When I had to read a book for my anthropology class, I had to not only write a summary of the book but give an oral presentation. This forced me to engage with the text at a personal and self-reflective way. As helpful as that was, teachers should take it a step further and not seek to get the right answer from the students in these papers, oral presentations, and written narrations, but instead allow the student to discover through indirect learning as they read the material for themselves.

Teachers need to recognize that students need to be given the chance to wrestle though material for themselves in order for them to take ownership in their learning. Edvard Grieg was asked by a famous Norwegian Poet named Henrik Ibsen to compose the music for a play he wrote called Peer Gynt. Delighted by the request, he accepted. It became the most difficult musical pieces he ever composed. He struggled through if from beginning to end. The end result: Peer Gynt Suite No. 1, Op. 46 and Peer Gynt Suite No. 2, Op. 55. This music became a raging hit in 1880 and 1881, and this music was what launched Edvard Grieg to fame. It is in the most difficult struggles that we learn that most and accomplish what seems like an impossibility. It is through the most difficult that a student becomes. Teachers need to give the space in their classrooms for this kind of struggle to take pace. How does a teacher accomplish this. Created a classroom where students can invent, create, play, fail, recreate and in the end, hopefully succeed.  I read about this school that was set up in this way. They had a classroom for science, filled with all sorts of science books, microscopes, lab equipment, and supplies for every imaginable experiment. Science teachers were in the classroom overseeing but never directly teaching. One of the students wanted to make a vodka distiller. The teacher made sure the supplies were there and allowed the student time and space to accomplish it. Over time, and through trial and error, he did. The lessons learned through that process- innumerable. Do you think this student ever forgot the lessons he learned through this process. I doubt it. Teachers in Universities can not necessarily organizer a classrooms in this way, but they can make room in their classroom for this sort of learning to take place. Maybe when dissecting a piglet the student could write a personal essay on the process to make it their own… (Finish!)

Teachers have been given this unique opportunity to sit in the front seat as students emancipate themselves from a passive style of learning to become sovereign individuals who learn for themselves. The job of an educator is not easy and it is not straight forward either. In the times we live, there are layers of methodology and state mandatory tests to quantify and regulate learning in students. The job of the educator can be accomplished through stimulating profound questions and conversation with students so the student engages intellectually in their education, through partnership with the students in the way the teacher evaluates academic progress, through presenting material indirectly through reading living books, and by allowing students to wrestle through material. An educator who teaches without teaching helps students to become, and this becoming is what produces leaders who make a lasting difference. 

800 word draft

Meghan Kidd and Samantha Pawluczyk
Randell Cream
Writing 120
08 November 2019
Teaching Without Teaching
In Walker Percy’s, “The Loss of the Creature”, he explains how the most effective way of learning is through the process of indirect learning. This means students are able to grasp the concept of a topic when it is brought to their attention in other ways than having to sit in a class and being lectured at by a professor. If a professor wants their students to truly learn a subject, they will create different ways of challenging his or her students into learning the topic inside and out. For example, microeconomics 112 is a three day class per week and consists of a teacher lecturing to the students for a fifty minute period. What if the agenda of the course changed: Mondays would be a lecturing day, Wednesdays would be an open discussion group with prompts created by the students themselves, and Fridays would be dedicated to fieldwork outside of the classroom. Requiring students to teach others and lead classes, partake in fieldwork once a week to give them real experience, and have a group discussion in the classroom weekly are all ways to get the students to learn without being taught.
The main goal of each professor is to get their students to fully understand their topic for the specific class in which they are taking. For example, a microeconomics professor works hard to break down economics in numerous ways to try to successfully have the students wrap their heads around how a business runs efficiently. One way of indirectly teaching his or her students, the economics professor could design a mandatory project where students are required to teach at least three other students about their major. By doing this, it forces the student to learn the topic more because they will need to be able to break it down and explain it. With this assignment, students will work to ensure they know the subject inside and out because they will have to teach it to students who do not take an economics class at all. However, this will not educate the other students who are not taking economics, rather the idea of this project is to teach the economic students without having to sit in a class and listen to their professor lecture at them day after day.
Aside from teaching students who do not take economics, another method teachers could use to get his or her student engaged in class is to have student-led classes. In order to be most efficient, it is recommended by the professor to work in groups of three or four. As students work in groups, this allows them to bounce ideas off one another which helps to indirectly teach each other. This course will be held three times a week and with that, there will be allotted time for each student group to lead a lesson at the beginning of each class. The groups will be in a rotation so each class has a new group presenting a lesson for about 20-25 minutes. This amount of time gives the students the ability to teach their lesson but enough time for the professor to give a revised lesson to the class. In Percy’s article he explains, “If we look into the ways in which the student can recover the dogfish (or the sonnet), we will see that they have in common the stratagem of avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned and restoring access to sonnet and dogfish as beings to be known, reasserting the sovereignty of knower over known.” Here, Percy explains the idea of sovereignty and how it is the surrender of power to the experts. This connects to this idea of student-led lessons because the professor is surrendering his position in order to give that same power to his or her students.
Each week the students gather in a classroom on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays in the early morning hours at 8:00am to learn about their intended course, microeconomics 112. However, the question is, how much information are the students really absorbing during that time? This class is fifty minutes in length and consists of a group of thirty students that have grown tired due to the fact of an early morning class and a professor that lectures to them the whole time without holding any type of conversation. Therefore, every Friday class should be dedicated as a fieldwork day. If the students are given one day each week to have hands on learning in economics, they might be able to learn more because of the interactions they will be having. For example, in the beginning of the year the professor will make each student pick a local businesses in town to study how the store measures their supply and demand and other factors that keep the company in business. Additionally, they will be able to talk to the workers at the store and ask for advice about their future and their potential career in economics. In addition, the students will have to get a weekly form signed stating that they were present for an hour at the business of their choice to ensure that they were of attendance.
Furthermore, one last method that would indirectly teach students more about their subject would be to have weekly discussions between the students. The most effective way of holding these discussions would be to have a standard lecture on Monday, followed by the group discussions on Wednesday. The professor would give a certain amount of information on Monday and students would be required to come up with at least three questions regarding the lecture. This would help to get the students more involved in the lectures rather than going to class and zoning out. Students would have to submit their questions on D2L so when they arrived at class, they would be ready to go through the list of questions and converse. The benefits of this method of learning is to have students answer other students questions and teach one another. The professor would sit in on this discussion and chime in if there were any major questions to avoid getting off track. This is an effective way of learning because it is a form of teamwork which helps each student get a better understanding of the class.
Learning effectively in the classroom is sometimes hard due to some students just sitting at their desks inattentive and unfocused, while their professor is in the front of the room throwing words around that come natural to him or her, but are unknown to the students. However if the students are required to teach others and lead classes, partake in fieldwork once a week to give them real experience, and have an open group discussions so that they have the ability to actually learn the subject. By changing the layout of the class schedule, students are being given the best possible foundation to succeed. Students are the future and should be given the best possible teaching methods to prepare them for their upcoming careers.

css.php