Positive: I like all the ideas you have about getting the students more involved in learning so that they will actually learn
Constructive: Some parts dont flow as well or seem wordy
Percy: Good use of Percy throughout the essay
Category: Weekly Responses
draft 2 reviews
John camperson:
praise: Your essay is put together nicely
constructive: reword sentences, try and find new words
Percy: quotes worked well with your topic
Amanda Regan:
Praise: overall a well put together essay
constructive: try and add more Percy throughout the essay
Percy: quotes are good, but need more
Comments on Kira Aves 2/3 project
Praise: I like the supporting detail you chose in order to complete this topic because this topic was challenging.
Negative: Build upon this and be a little more descriptive. Good topic just be a little more specific
Percy: Great quote. Really outlines your topic. Allows for you to build upon this
Comments on Julia D
Positive: I think you have some great ideas that are explained well
Constructive: There are some spelling errors and a few grammatical errors
Percy: I think the places you have set out for your quotes are good spots but I dont know how they will look without actually seeing them
Draft review on Jake Drap’s team
Praise- I like the comparison between high school education and college education. Relating your ideas to the real world keeps a reader intrigued in your essay.
Constructive- More analytical work necessary within your paragraphs. Make sure to reread your essay and look for grammar mistakes.
Percy- Your quotes are very good and can go along with your work well, they just have to be worked into the essay a little better.
Comment to Riley and Gabby
Positive: Very well written thesis. You have four strong main points and I believe all of these would help in learning
Negative: Maybe add a quote in this paragraph other than that great job
Percy: Great job on choosing the quotes. They relate to your thesis statement.
Comment to Gabe Jasinski
Positive: Very well written. I like how you explained that outside of the classroom experience is important in learning
Negative: Not really anything negative to say besides this should be MLA or APA
Percy: You did a good job explaining the quotes. Makes it easy to understand
John Camperson draft 2 peer revision
constructive: I think some sentences need to be worked on to work well better.
positive: I think that this is a very good essay and very well put together. I think it blended together really well.
Percy: I think your quotes were used very well and worked with the essay
Peer review Galilea, Drap, Evans
Praise: The example used allow the reader to gain more interest.
Constructive:Grammer
Percy: The use of percy works well with what you are discussing.
Sam Livorno big draft review
positive: I really like your ideas and how you incorperated Percy. Your paragraphs blend very well.
constructive: you should introduce Percy in your opening paragraph
Percy: I like your use of quotes they go very well with your ideas.
comments on laura’s long draft
Praise: You explain your topic very well in your body paragraphs
Constructive: You could explain a little bit more in detail in your opening
Percy: your quotes explain your points well.
comments on amanda R
Praise: your opening is well put together and explains your topic well
Constructive: Could introduce percy a little bit better
Percy: Your quotes are good but could be more detailed in the analysis.
Peer review for Kira Aves
Praise:Your first paragraph draws in the reader and makes you look forward to the rest of the paper.
Constructive: Bring more attention to your use of Percy.
Percy:The quotes used work well with your essay.
Haley Myers Long Draft Review
Mia Positive- I think you have a strong thesis and intro paragraph that clearly highlights your points and gives good insight on the rest of your paper.
Mia Constructive- Sometimes less is more in terms of sentence structure. I feel like there are a couple run-on sentences and repetitive sentences that when corrected can make your writing flow more.
Mia Percy- I think you have strong quotes from the text for all of your points that back them up very well.
Emily Positive- I can really connect to your writing being a student here at WCU. I feel like all of your points are valid and make sense coming from a student.
Emily Constructive- In your third paragraph I think it would be a good idea to end with a sentence that sums up the overall idea/ point of that paragraph to sum things up.
Emily Percy- All of your quotes strongly support your points and they are all cited properly and placed within a sentence. In your second paragraph I would try to expand on the quote after it is cited.
800 words peer review on Rabi
Praise: I like your idea of how a student should have study and review sessions arranged outside. I agree that students will learn better when they see another student at WCU studying outside instead of the 4 walls in the classroom.
Constructive: Your paper is good, but I believe you haven’t completed the assignment.
Percy: Your quotes support well with your paper.
Leah:
Praise: Your paper makes sense. It shows how students should learn outside of the teacher. Your topics make sense and it is well written.
Constructive: for your thesis, make sure you state “I believe good teaching at wcu can happen by a,b,c,d” Make sure you state your four topics in your last sentence.
Percy: You did a good job explaining the quotes meanings after you used them in the text. It allows us to understand.
800 words peer review on Emily’s Team
Praise: I agree with your concept of how education beyond the major allows students to be able to gain a better education package, learn from their failures, expecting higher education experts. That is up to students to take the package and make the usage of it
Constructive: I don’t understand if you’re stating that the package is good or not. I think you need to focus on that more.
Percy: Your text supports your paper, but you need to explain more about the education package.
Leah:
Praise: Your thesis is well thought out. All of your points make sense and can change the students at West Chester. I liked your point of talking about if a student fails a gen-ed. It does hopefully make students focus and want to pass.
Constructive: Is the package good? I am a little confused if it is good or bad (idk if I am just dumb).
Percy: All of the quotes make sense. You connect them with the passage, and it all flows together. Very strong quotes.
Amandas Team Long Draft Review
Mia Positive- I think its good that you have an example of an actual class here at WCU and how it does not reflect the author’s ideas. In the sentence before I would change “That” to “Where” teachers teach.
Mia Constructive- In your second paragraph, I would try to expand on the idea. Maybe add a quote from the text of one of the authors to back up the idea of trial and error.
Mia Percy- In the second paragraph, explain how it will benefit the students at West Chester based on Percy’s views
Emily Positive- I think you have a strong fourth paragraph. Randall tells us to place our points within the essay from strongest to weakest and I would put that one first. (The one with teachers creating activities based on students teaching students the information)
Emily Constructive- When putting a quote in your text, it is not good to start out with just the quote as you did in paragraph number 4. For example your quote in your third paragraph starts with , “A quote from Percy states,” but in the fourth paragraph it starts out with just the quote.
Emily Percy- In your introduction, you have a class that does not follow the author’s views on teaching. If there is one or an example of one, talk about a class that does follow their views and why it is better for education.
Draft Review on Kira Aves
Praise: Your essay is extremely well written. You use a lot of examples and your paragraphs are developed and really though out.
Constructive: If you can develop your fourth sub point the same way you did with the other three, the essay will be nearly perfect.
Percy: The analysis of the Percy quotes in your essay are depth and explains how it relates to your topic.
Draft Review on Jake Drap’s Team
Praise: I really like how you are including real world examples into your piece. It makes it strong for the analysis portion of the paragraph.
Constructive: Check some of the punctuation and beef up the paragraphs a little bit more.
Percy: Your Percy quotes are good, you just need to integrate them into the paragraphs and explain how they relate to the topic.
Peer Review DiGiorgio
Percy :
Use of Percy and Freire is good, but try to implement them earlier into writing.Reply•Resolve
Constructive:
Second paragraph needs more body to it. Try to introduce the solution or point first then explain what it will accomplish.Reply•Resolve
Praise:
Your intro is well rounded and explains the problem at hand while supported by both Percy and Freire.