Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Responses – Page 21 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Peer review topic proposal

Emily Strassner

Praise: I like how the quotes connect with the idea of indirect education is necessary for students in order to create critical thinking.

Constructive: I understand your idea, but you should add more about how unrelated courses are necessary for students and how it could impact their education in their major.

Percy: Your quotes and ideas, support Percy ideas on how symbolic complex break the idea of students to learn something for themselves.

Peer Review topic proposal

Laura McGroary

Praise: Your ideas in your thesis and quotes connect with what your try to explain.

Percy: Your thesis is very well connect to Percy’s ideas. This quote goes very well with how students have a precoincived ideas of what they will learn.

Constructive: You introduce very well the problem students have in WCU, you should complete in your thesis how the problem at WCU could be solve.

Comments on Kyle Owens and Rabi Muhammad

Kyle : good points, and ideas on topic support and analytical presentation will be the essential part

More specific on the thesis statement, should be a definitive statement

Good use of the Percy quote, in understanding that the educator cannot be part of the solution

Rabi :positive and neg
good thesis, and relation to Percy, more specific in sub points though, like list the strategies.
on Percy: good quote to support thesis

Topic Proposal Peer Review

Haley Myers

Praise: You have good ideas and I like how you incorporated that students learn differently.
Constructive: Your thesis is more as an intro than a thesis. A thesis should be short and concise. Your last example of how it can be recovered does not have a lot of information. So try and get more reasons to support it.
Percy: Good use of Percy, just integrate the quotes into how one is able to learn outside the classroom.

Peer review

Meghan Kidd & Sam Pawluczk

Praise: I like your connection to the beaten path and general education classes. This is a strong argument.

Constructive: Your thesis needs more added to how classes outside of the major are beneficial.

Percy: Your use of quotes from Percy matches the information that you want to talk about.

Peer review

Haley Myers

Praise: I really like your idea! You have a very strong thesis and very strong ideas!

Constructive: You need more information on how you are you are going to use the discussion groups.

Percy: You have a good idea for how you are going to apply Percy to your idea.

Topic Proposal Peer Review

Megan Kidd and Sam Pawluczyk

Praise: I like the quotes you choose to support your ideas and thesis.

Constructive: Your thesis needs to be stronger and include general education instead of listing arts, ethics, etc. It also is negative, try to include how it is beneficial.

Percy: I feel like your quotes from Percy go well with the ideas.

topic proposal review

John Camperson

praise – your thesis is good! i like how you talk about how students should be utilizing their time. you are off to a good start.

constructive – I think that you should talk more about places students can go to get work done and also talk about ways that students can learn outside of the classroom

Percy – I think your quotes fit well, but you should talk about Percy more in your thesis.

Julia DiGiorgio- Proposal comments

Julia- Terrific start!

1 praise- I like what you say in your thesis: “There are other classes to take that open up students ideas giving them more knowledge and challenges to complete.” This is helpful to keep in mind, especially when we don’t prefer a class- looking to see what we can learn from it is a good practice to establish. It is also helpful to see how seemingly unrelated topics/classes actually do relate.

1 constructive- your first sub-point can be a little tricky to practically implement. I would make sure to give strong supporting ideas and application to go with that point.

Percy quote- The quotes are great! I think they go well with the two points you have.

Grady Leonard – Proposal comments

Grady, This is a really good start. Your thesis is engaging and draws the reader in. I would have liked to see the two sub-points clearly defined in this proposal. I can see how your first quote compliments your thesis, the second quote might be a stretch. If you use the second quote, make your supporting arguments reinforce the main idea of the quote.

Topic Proposal Peer Review

Maddie Barker

Criticism: I would make your thesis a little stronger but it is a good idea.

Percy: This quote from Percy is a great one to use for your ideas. I think you can use this for strong support for your thesis. This is a great use of Percy.

Praise: I like how you explain which classes can help with different aspects for things other than your major.

Topic Proposal Peer Review

Laura McGroary

Percy: You have a good use of Percy in your thesis. It shows you will be connecting your ideas to his

Constructive: Be a little more clear on what they experience when they arrive.

Praise: I like this quote and I think it will be good to use to support your ideas.

Topic Proposal Peer Review

Jake Drap, Tyler Evans, Cristian Galilea

Praise: I think your thesis has a lot of good ideas and plenty of room to branch off of and write a powerful and persuasive paper.

Constructive: However I believe that if you included Percy’s ideas or just compare him to support your ideas in your thesis then it will be a lot more powerful and you will get your points across better.

Percy: I think the quotes that you do have support your thesis and i believe Percy would agree with your thesis.

Topic Proposal Peer Review

Sabrina Lindley

Praise: I think your topic proposal is very well written and hits all the major supporting points that you are aiming to hit in your thesis statement.

Percy: You use Percy’s writing well to your advantage to support your ideas as well.

Constructive: However I think your quotes could be stronger to truly support the powerful fix on the situation you already have.

Proposal Peer Review

Amanda Jiang and Leah Schreffler

1 praise: Your thesis is well thought out and your ideas so far will greatly support your topic. I think if the learning process at WCU was altered to your suggestions, then it would help students learn more effectively. While it may be a bit more challenging and not let students “get by” as easily, it will ultimately enhance their comprehension and critical thinking skills in the long run.

1 constructive: Maybe try elaborating more on how classroom interaction will allow students to become more involved. Will this be something that the professor has to initiate, or will it solely be based off student to student discussion?

Use of Percy: I think the two quotes you picked out will greatly strengthen your essay, especially Percy’s idea on the “educational package”. This will be good to explain Percy’s view on the education system and how it relates to/supports your ideas for altering the teaching practices at WCU.

Proposal Peer Review

Haley Myers

1 praise: I think your intro is well-worded and that you have some solid ideas to support your thesis. I especially think your idea to promote field trips and studying abroad as a way of learning outside the classroom would be very beneficial to students, and you used Freire and Percy’s ideas to support it well. 

1 constructive: Maybe try to incorporate Percy and his ideas in your intro/thesis to show how it will relate to your ideas. (ex. the idea that Percy thinks learning is most effective when students willingly go out on their own to learn and get the true experience). 

Use of Percy: I think the quotes you chose will greatly support your essay. This quote, “Our complex friend stands behind his fellow tourists at the Bright Angel Lodge and sees the canyon through them and their predicament, their picture taking and busy disregard. In a sense, he exploits his fellow tourists; he stands on their shoulders to see the canyon” will especially support Percy’s idea that when people go to experience things for themselves for the first time, they are too busy taking pictures and capturing the moment instead of really soaking in and appreciating the experience they’re having. 

css.php