https://docs.google.com/document/d/13xbC3M1sBNjJ_KJ-8H1cw1N3GzaP0ga1L1lfrusLs8A/edit
Category: Weekly Responses
Writing Project 2, Topic Proposal
Topic 1:
Thesis Statement: Throughout school we have many classes that are not needed for our degree but taking courses that are different from your major will help enforce students to engage in their academic life to really think about what they want and if the field they picked was right for them.
Subpoint:
Sub-point 1: With taking many classes that may be necessary for your major will only help the students learn what they are interested in and not interested in.
Sub-point 2: Having such a broad horizon of classes will give students and appreciation for every class and major that they might of thought differently about.
Quote:
Quote 1: “Their hope has something to do with their own role as tourists in a foreign country and the way in which they conceive this role.” (Percy Page 2)
Quote 2: “To put it bluntly: A student who has the desire to get at a dogfish or a Shakespeare sonnet may have the greatest difficulty in salvaging the creature itself from the educational package in which it is presented.” (Percy Page 4)
Writing Project 2- Topic Proposal
Topic: 1- Education Beyond the Major
Team: Emily Strassner
Working Thesis: Education beyond a student’s chosen major is critical to their personal development. Enrolling in courses unrelated to one’s major results in the bettering of a student as an individual and a problem solver.
Supporting Ideas & Quotes:
“The highest role of the educator is the maieutic role of Socrates: to help the student come to himself not as a consumer of experience but as a sovereign individual,” (Percy 6). Percy supports the idea that teachers are meant to not only teach students academic information, but also to teach them to become independent. Teachers are not meant to distribute information, they are rather meant to assist students in discovering the material for themselves.
“I propose that English poetry and biology should be taught as usual, but that at irregular intervals, poetry students should find dogfishes on their desks and biology students should find Shakespeare sonnets on their dissection boards,” (Percy 6). Percy agrees with the focus of students’ on their intended major, but believes that much can be learned from thinking outside of the box. By providing students’ with knowledge unrelated to their major, problem solving and critical thinking is enforced.
Project #2 Proposal
Team Jason Riberio and David Heffron
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1j1L4DENX_Fl0MmtePP6AR8XYaMdg1Ob9ecbXimHNpd4/edit?usp=sharing
Writing Project 2 Proposal
https://docs.google.com/document/d/13d_VrkST1_8VmrfFOheCbjrxUYxJ3knc7tXxcDSPreU/edit
Topic 1
Education beyond the major. You’re getting a degree in something, but mostly you’re not: majors have between 40 and 60 credits within the field, leaving most of the degree spent elsewhere. How does education beyond the major work for students who are focused on (x) but taking (y)? Identify the problem and then use the work of Percy (and Freire as desired) to assert (at least) four ways in which education beyond the major supports significant, necessary learning at WCU. Each of your ideas must be supported by critical ideas from the work of Percy.
Topic Selection: 1- Education beyond the major
Team Selection: Abbey Johnson, Isabella DeSario, Nick Nolan
Working Thesis: When working to get a degree in college it is important to focus on courses that are directly related to one’s field of study, while also getting a well rounded education and opening one’s eyes to a variety of experiences and fields.
Sub Points:
- Students become more prepared to face a wider variety of issues in their career that classes specific to their major might not directly address
- Students become more well rounded in the learning and understanding of the world
Supporting Ideas:
- “For there is nothing the educator can do to provide for this need of the student. Everything the educator does only succeeds in becoming, for the student, part of the educational package. The highest role of the educator is the maieutic role of Socrates: to help the student come to himself not as a consumer of experience but as a sovereign individual.” (Percy 6)
- “It may be recovered by leaving the beaten track. The tourist leaves the tour, camps in the back country. He arises before dawn and approaches the South Rim through a wild terrain where there are no trails and no railed-in lookout points. In other words, he sees the canyon by avoiding all the facilities for seeing the canyon.” (Percy 1)
Project 2 Topic Proposal
Topic proposal 2
Topic Proposal 2
Topic #2
Most of your time is spent outside of class so that leaves you with many opportunities to learn outside of class. There are many things you could do to learn outside of the classroom you could join a club which relates to the subject(If you are taking a computer science class you could join the computer club), Learn more about it by looking it up on the internet, and go over what you learned in class. In a classroom the teacher might not be effective in teaching the subject or it simply requires more time than is available in the classroom to learn it so in order to learn you need to spend some time outside the classroom to effectively learn the subject. You must find the best way to learn yourself for some simply memorizing something might be enough but most of the time deeper learning must be used like by learning a math problem you simply try to do it by using trial and error you will learn more from that then looking up how to do it because you learned it yourself(This relates to Percy’s idea of taking the unbeaten path, the learner instead of using a path that was made for him like a youtube video explaining it solves it themselves). You could go to a club or a tutorer or simply another class mate and try to learn from them allowing a similar environment to the classroom to learn in. You can look at the notes you took in class to make sure you learned what was taught to you in class which if you don’t feel like you understood it completely you could go on the internet to teach yourself or go to someone who could teach it to you. This allows for a student to learn in a way that more suits them.
Percy idea that I don’t know how to fit in
- The fact that the subjects you are learning have been taught to millions of people might take the value away from learning it you could see it as just another basic to be learned but it should be viewed to you as just as important as learning something that was never known before because it is new to you and you need that knowledge.
- Being taught something is not as efficient as learning it yourself. You need to keep your sovereignty and not give it away to someone so they could teach it to you. You could still learn the topic but it is better to let your self struggle to learn it yourself in order to most effectively learn it. If you give it to someone else they will try to teach it to you on their terms which you have to try to meet in order to learn it.
- In Percy’s example of the dogfish the student learns more by interacting with it themselves without being given any instructions but simply an objective this allows for the student to learn most effectively by discovering it themselves
Project #2 proposal
Project Proposal 2
Project Proposal #2
Writing Project 2
Topic proposal for Project 2
topic proposal #2
Writing project 2 proposal
Topic Proposal Project #2
project proposal #2
Topic proposal
Ethan Stein
Topic # 1: Education beyond the major
Team: Ethan Stein
Thesis: Most of students time at West Chester University are spent outside their major because it because it opens them up to new ideas and challenges them in ways they aren’t used too.
- Sub point 1: New ideas and broadens their horizons.
- Sub point 2: Challenges them in ways they are not used to.
- Supporting ideas- Percy talk about how the grand canyon is hyped up so much that when people see it they are left disappointed but at west chester it’s actually the opposite. When students take classes they hear bad things about they don’t take them go in with a bad attitude even though they might actually enjoy it
- Supporting ideas- When Garcia Lopez de Cárdenas discovered the Grand Canyon he was amazed by it even more because of the challenge it gave him. When taking a class someone isn’t used to it helps them figure out how to study or how to learn.
PROJECT 2 PROPOSAL
Topic Proposal
Topic 1
Team: Lauren Beccaria, Sami Kakar, Jeff Biancaniello
Thesis: Although it is important to focus on a major, it is necessary to take courses in other fields to create the well rounded education of an individual so they can be prepared for anything in their future endeavors.
Points
- Creates well rounded knowledge in students
- Makes students prepared for more problems that they might run into outside their major
Supporting ideas from percy
- Educational package
- Sovereignty
Quotes:
- “To put it bluntly: A student who has the desire to get at a dogfish or a Shakespeare sonnet may have the greatest difficulty in salvaging the creature itself from the educational package in which it is presented.”
- “If we look into the ways in which the student can recover the dogfish (or the sonnet), we will see that they have in common the stratagem of avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned and restoring access to sonnet and dogfish as beings to be known, reasserting the sovereignty of knower over known.”