https://docs.google.com/document/d/1oLECjz6gECvzA9FCkr2Rh_2mKze37HZpRq_xwS2okAs/edit?usp=sharing
Category: Weekly Responses
writing project 2 topic proposal
Topic Selection : Topic 1
Team: Sarah Veneziale and Cait Mangini
Working Thesis: The problem of the student is the loss of sovereignty and to become the knower again can occur from the education outside of their major. By taking other classes not necessary for one’s major, they will bring a sense of having back up plans, rekindle a love for learning, provide more chances to find happiness, and save time if having to switch career paths.
Two ideas with two supporting quotes:
- Many students may have a preconceived idea of what their future job will be, like the tourist saw when he got to the grand canyon and compared it to the postcards. Preconceived ideas may ruin the job in the future, so having experience in other classes outside major can help them find other interests as backup plans. This can lead to a major change, will ultimately make the student more happy.
- “It is almost impossible because the Grand Canyon, the thing as it is, has been appropriated by the symbolic complex which has already been formed in the sightseer’s mind.” (Percy 1)
- For the love of learning. In Percy’s piece he talks about how a boy who found a dogfish compared to a student who has to dissect a dogfish for class is more likely to remember the situation. The boy is excited to dissect the fish and is doing it for fun, but the student has to do this. The boy although may not understand exactly what he is doing, he is enjoying and going to memorize this moment better than a student who is forced to do so. Taking classes outside of one’s major creates a non forced environment. Knowing they don’t have to take this class necessary for their major, they are not as pressured and can enjoy the experience.
- “A young Falkland Islander walking along a beach and spying a dead dogfish and going to work on it with his jackknife has, in a fashion wholly unprovided in modern educational theory, a great advantage over the Scarsdale high-school pupil who finds the dogfish on his laboratory desk.” (Percy 4)
Discussion #5
Isabella,TJ,RJ, Nick
Leader did not show up.
Topic Proposal
Topic proposal
Proposal Peer Review
Emily Foley’s Team
Constructive- How does education beyond the major apply to a student’s focus? How can students gain focus from this? Needs more explanation
Praise- using the “cookie cutter” analogy is a good depiction of saying that there is no variation in learning, it is a good visualization support for individualism
Percy- good quote by Percy about poetry student finding dogfish on desk. By surprising students, they are able to get other perspectives on different learning subjects.
Peer Proposal Review
David MacMullen
Constructive- Internships are a good idea to learn outside of the classroom- but this only applies to upper class man because freshman are not prepared yet to participate in internships in their field.
Positive- I like the idea of off and on campus community to build characteristics for professional jobs and learn real world things rather than just textbook information.
Use of Percy- quote about “creative power” is a good way to support the idea of on and off campus activities to express yourself in a different environment other than the classroom.
Jake Heikkinen Writing Project 2 Topic Proposal
Proposal Peer Review
Jenna and Kenzie
Constructive: I feel two of your topics blend together. Gaining interpersonal skills and critical thinking skills should be merged as one topic since they both create skills needed for the workforce. Gaining interpersonal skills is your weakest solution so combining it with critical thinking would make it stronger.
Praise: Your thesis is very clear, concise, and strong. The quote used for critical thinking I think can be strongly used to aid how classes outside your major will benefit one to develop skills one will use in their profession.
Percy: Your use of Percy is very strong and aligns well with each way to seek education beyond the major; however, I would look to expand more on Percy’s ideas to emphasize how these classes outside one’s major is essential for their success for their future career.
Proposal Peer Review:
Gwen Jordan, Makayla Medycki, Maura Kelly
Constructive: I think you should move your thesis before you first sentence and get straight to the point and then explain it in your intro in which the first sentence does. If I’m right I believe the sentence starting with “taking credits” is your thesis. I feel two of your solutions are 1 of the same.
Extra Feedback: In addition, I think you need to expand on the connection to Percy and identify how these outside-major classes promote students, like why would this help a student more than their major classes? Getting more experience in other subjects and gaining outside knowledge are similar in that you gain outside knowledge from experience in other subjects so I would merge the two together and create another solution.
Praise: Overall, I think the ideas you created for education beyond the major are going to help your essay flow well and they are very clear solutions. For gain of outside knowledge talk about how it gives them more opportunities for careers because one will have background in other curriculars to add to resume.
Percy: I think your second quote goes really well hand in hand with understanding of others to work in different situations.
Proposal Peer Review:
Haley Myers
Praise: I think that the ideas you have created for education outside of the classroom are going to make your essay very strong, and help you to use Percy and Freire.
Constructive: Expand on this with connection to Percy.
For example:
Students constantly find themselves in the predicament in that the information presented in class isn’t clearly comprehended, Percy identifies this as the prepackaged ideas of a teacher. Everyone learns differently whether students learn visually, auditory, or physically. In this essay I will use Percy’s ideas to accommodate for all learners. Education outside the classroom will help students grasp complex information presented in class to improve their comprehension of their desired major and minor of study through tutoring, field trips, study abroad, discussion groups and internships.
Percy: I think that your use of Percy here is strong, Percy discusses that we need to see things for ourselves, learning outside the classroom is crucial, but only if the student gets rid of the pre packaged idea. Field trips and studying abroad can still become the banking concept of education… how can we make sure it doesn’t become that?
Kyle Owens
Praise: I think that this is essential for this topic, all students know how they learn best, to implement Percy in this you can say that students don’t learn from a prepackaged idea that the teacher creates… students have to learn for themselves
Constructive: Your thesis needs more to it, and you can not identify the professor, the topic is all about the students
For example:
As Percy has identified, the educator can do nothing for the student. In order to achieve teaching without teaching here at West Chester University, classrooms need to become more student based and incorporate styles of learning that benefit the student individually.
Percy: Another quote that I think would benefit your paper is from page 6. “For there is nothing the educator can do to provide for this need of the student, everything the educator does only succeeds in becoming, for the student, part of the educational package.”
Topic Proposal
Group: Donny Lessing, Tj Fitzpatrick, Nick Gamba
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fPg3Ktpgt8BJKYqn7h_3egK2Tz-TYcFqAa8hZG3a_yQ/edit?usp=sharing
Project 2 Topic Proposal
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uPp1hdq0gLUIcOKavUF8CGnDUAWy9B8FaiNRqFbVzqk/edit?usp=sharing
Adam Griffin
Topic Proposal
Learning outside the classroom. Although it’s a cliche to say that what goes on outside the classroom is as important as what goes on inside each class, do the math. Each 3-credit class you take involves 37.5 hours of class-time across 15 weeks, or about 2.5 hours a week. For a full load of 5 classes, that’s only 12.5-14 hours of class time a week, far short of what should be expected in a work situation (40 hours) or what you did last year in high school (30 hours). How should students at WCU, and the institution itself, leverage that time for transformative learning? Identify the problem and then use the work of Percy (and Freire if desired) to assert (at least) four ways in which learning beyond the classroom supports, or could support, something at the core of the student experience at WCU. Your ideas must be supported by four critical ideas from the work of Percy.
Team: Just me
Topic: 2 “Learning outside the classroom”
Thesis: The transition from high school to college affects many students, one main thing that affects students the most is the amount of outside of classwork needs to do. In highschool students spend on average 30 hours in school. In that period students would talk to peers about assignments and socialize in school as well as keeping up with their education. Compared to college where students only spend 12.5 – 14 hours of class time in a week, they need to spend more time outside of the classroom. At West Chester University students can learn outside the classroom by discussion groups, tutoring, and internships/studying abroad.
Discussion Groups: Discussion groups help students learn outside the classroom by socializing and bouncing ideas off of each other. Students can work together to open the package of education that they have been banked from the professor.
Tutoring: Seeking a tutor can help students in many ways. Students can ask questions that they did not present to the teacher during class time. Tutoring can also help clear up confusion of notes because the tutor can present it to you in a different way that the student might understand better.
Quote 1: “Does this mean that we should get rid of museums? No, but it means that the sightseer should be prepared to enter into a struggle to recover a sight from a museum” (Percy 6).
Quote 2: “In this process, arguments based on “authority” are no longer valid; in order to function, the authority must be on the side of freedom, not against it. Here, no one teaches another, nor is anyone self-taught. People teach each other, mediated by the world, by the cognizable objects which in banking education are “owned” by the teacher.”(Freire 4)
Quote 3: “It is only the rarest student who knows that the sonnet must be salvaged from the package”(Percy 4)
Writing Project #2
Team Members: Grady Leonard
Topic: The campus and the community. We go to town for yogurt (no! have some acai instead) or whatever, but most of us don’t really have a sense of community beyond the campus at WCU. We can do better. We must do better. How should students at WCU, and the institution itself, interact with the community beyond the campus in order to achieve the goals for transformative learning? Identify the problem and then use the work of Percy and Freire to assert (at least) four ways in which WCU could use our non-campus community to support something at the core of the student experience at WCU. Your ideas must be supported by four critical ideas from the work of Percy (and Freire if desired).
Working Thesis: With the wonderful town of West Chester just steps away from the University, it is heinous how uninvolved the students are with the community as a whole. Students need to become more involved in the community by doing things such as participating in community events, volunteering throughout the community, get a job in town, or even have the community have more influence on the University as a whole.
Percy Quotes:
“The tourist who carves his initials in a public place, which is theoretically “his” in the first place, has good reasons for doing so, reasons which the exhibitor and planner know nothing about. He does so because in his role of consumer of an experience (a “recreational experience” to satisfy a “recreational need”) he knows that he is disinherited. He is deprived of his title over being. He knows very well that he is in a very special sort of zone in which his only rights are the rights of a consumer. He moves like a ghost through schoolroom, city streets, trains, parks, movies. He carves his initials as a last desperate measure to escape his ghostly role of consumer. He is saying in effect: I am not a ghost after all; I am a sovereign person. And he establishes title the only way remaining to him, by staking his claim over one square inch of wood or stone.”
“The sonnet is obscured by the symbolic package which is formulated not by the sonnet itself but by the media through which the sonnet is transmitted, the media which the educators believe for some reason to be transparent. The new textbook, the type, the smell of the page, the classroom, the aluminum windows and the winter sky, the personality of
Miss Hawkins—these media which are supposed to transmit the sonnet may only succeed in transmitting themselves.”
Topic Proposal
Topic Proposal
Topic Proposal Project 2
WRT Project 2 Proposal
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1swjgjoyoMF1XByZ17g95zTQ1VxDEU96lJcrZ1U-nejs/edit
Team: Amanda Jiang and Leah Schreffler
Topic Proposal: Teaching without teaching:
Working Thesis:
Good quality teaching involves interaction and socialization between students. A good professor takes time to understand the student’s background and needs. The teacher builds a relationship with the student. Teachers take shortcuts by posting powerpoints and feeding the information to the students instead of taking the time to teach the content of the class, this way goes against Percy’s and Freire’s ideas of teaching. The way the teacher can teach can be alternated by the students. Creating a learning environment where students are not taught by the teacher allows for a different way of learning. One class that West Chester offers is Transcultural health, a class that teachers teach students as passive objects. The object of this project is to create classes that transform students as passive objects to actively learning.
Two Supporting Ideas:
- Teachers assign assignments outside of the classroom where students are forced to teach themselves from observation. Activities where students observe information outside of the classroom when you read or watch a video, you don’t learn as much as going somewhere are you observe for yourself.
- College is all about training students to be future leaders and for this to happen, students have to recognize that they have a voice and an opinion. Speaking for yourself is a hard thing to do and learn. Having interaction in the classroom and in the criteria of the course will allow students to learn to become involved in the class.
- Activities are created that will make students teach students the information.
Two Quotes:
“…that they have in common the stratagem of avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned and restoring access to sonnet and dogfish as beings to be known, reasserting the sovereignty of knower over known” (Percy 5).
“No, but it means that the student should know what a fight he has on his hands to rescue the specimen from the educational package. The educator is only partly to blame. For there is nothing the educator can do to provide for this need of the student. Everything the educator does only succeeds in becoming, for the student, part of the educational package” (Percy 5).
Weekly group
Group: Laura, Haley, Kira, Donny
In this group we talked about some similarities and differences between freire and Percy. We had really good talks about this and really figured out ways they were similar and different. Something that we thought was similar is that they both don’t exactly agree with teaching. They both think teaching is not learning. They are also different because Friere talks about experiencing things a lot and is really big on that. But percy says that if you go see the grand canyon since you didn’t discover the grand canyon it would be different. Percy thinks the fact that you could hear about the grand canyon from outside sources it would not make your experience as special. I feel like Friere would not agree with this and would think the experience would be worth going and learning about.
Discussion group response
Kyle Owens, Bella B, Jake D, Kenzie Neiderer, Jason Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian Galilea, David Heffron, Joshua Rogers, Muhammad Rabi, Jake Heikkinen, Sean Redding, Tyler Evans, Nick,Timothy Domanowski, Sam Livorno
In most of society, taking shortcuts has become the norm. Nobody wants to put in the work to do anything. This can be in everything from cooking a meal to education. Even the people who are supposed to be educating us are becoming lazy. With every answer at the tap of a button, it’s easier to just look things up instead of having to think for yourself. Students have started to just memorize and forget and teachers have started to just read off of the same powerpoints that they’ve used for the past *however many* years instead of actually teaching. Laziness has become part of our culture and we need to stop this while we can because if we don’t, my generation is going to destroy everything. With people becoming less and less motivated to try and care about anything, our society will begin to struggle because people are entitled. Whether it be education, jobs, or really anything, people from my generation haven’t had to work for anything. Things are just given to us and if we continue to be spoiled the way we are, eventually we won’t have things given to us and we will not be able to function as a society.