Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Responses – Page 40 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Response to Jake H

On Friday September 13 my group discussed what makes a teacher good and bad and how it relates to Freire “Banking concept of Learning”. A good teacher is someone who makes connections with their students and goes out of their way to get to know each student they teach. When teachers know what kind of learners they are teaching, the students tend to be more successful in the class. Another quality that makes the teacher good is when they engage their students rather than lecture them. In Freire concept of learning he talked about how teachers are only teaching their students by repeating information over and over until their students memorize it. This is an example of a bad teaching method, because in the end the students don’t know what they are actually learning. Freire also said that the teachers are there strictly to do their job, then leave. This is also a bad quality of a teacher, good teachers like their job and what their teaching.  

Group: Emily Foley, Makayla Medycki, Mia Citerone, Julia Digiorgio, Michael Lindholm, Gwen Jordan, Juiliana Benstien, Maura Kelly

Response to Sam Livorno (week 2)

During this discussion, we discussed about the third prompt of the writing project. We focused on two main questions which were, “How does a student befriend a professor?” and “Is it relatively easy or hard to establish a relationship with them?”. The whole group agreed that it depends on the personality of the student. Some students are open and have no problem establishing relationships but then there are the students who are introverted and struggle to get out of their comfort zone. We also talked about how the atmosphere of the classroom can affect the student to teacher relationship. For example, if the student has a class with students who are older and more involved, it might be difficult for the student to become comfortable with the class and the teacher. Another thing we talked about was the “gap” between students and teachers. Because the teacher is the boss to the student, it can be difficult for some students to look past this. We talked about different ways students can create relationships with their professors, such as sitting in front of the class, being involved in discussions, or just introducing themselves when they see their professor in public. Teachers have office hours which are specifically to help students. Teachers and students have to work together to create the relationship that is needed for success.

Leah Schreffler

Laura McGroary

Amanda Jiang

Sam Livorno

Response to Katherine Sola

Discussion Group: Katherine, Sam, Leann, and Jeff

In our discussion group we focused on two of Freire’s quotes where he stated, “the teacher teaches and the students are taught” and “the teachers know everything and the students know nothing”. We began our discussion by all agreeing that it is not true that all teachers know everything and that all students know nothing. We believe that there are many situations where students can teach teachers something they do not know much about or something completely new. We also identified that they can be situations where students may even be able to prove teachers wrong and that can be a learning experience for all. We also pointed out that this can depend on the teacher. Some teachers what student input so that both the teacher and the students can benefit from the different perspectives they all bring. Our group also believe that some students even prefer if other students teach them instead of the teacher. In order for that to happen the student teaching has to know the information and therefore he knows what the teacher knows. After we all shared our ideas we had other great conversations on various topics and went on our way. This was a group of great people.

response to Noah Heslop

Bella DiPasquale

Noah Heslop, Haley Myers, Nick Passis, Kyle Owens, Muhammad Rabi, Donny Lessing, and Sean Redding

West Chester University has a lot of “space” throughout campus.  Not only West Chester, but many other schools. In a lot of colleges there are lectures, lectures have a good amount of students in them so students feel less connected to their professors, which creates more space, and thats not always good. In smaller classrooms, there is less space and that helps students focus more, and feel more connected to their professors. Sometimes space can be a good thing, the space between classrooms can be helpful because the farter apart classrooms are in a buildings can help students focus more, because there is less noise. Although space can be good, its also good when there is not much space, like said before students can feel more connected in smaller classrooms. Even the smallest action of just having the professor know the students name can help them feel more involved, in lectures students don’t have that connection. Online classes are also an example of “space” and how students could feel less connected. Online classes might be helpful for some students, it might allow them to focus more, but it could also be bad for them. Students who take online classes could also get more distracted and then end up not understanding any of the material they need to learn.

Response to Noah Heslop

Leader: Noah Heslop

Participants: Nick Passis, Bella Dibasquale, Kyle Owens, Muhammad Rabi, Donny Lessing, and Sean Redding

In today’s discussion, we focused on a small classroom versus a lecture in comparison to one another. Riley provided the idea that both sizes of classrooms allow students to learn specific subjects, but smaller classrooms allow for more attention on a topic. Rather than a large room lecture, smaller, more interactive classrooms provide more hands-on help from the teacher and peer help from other students. In a building with smaller classrooms, the walls are thicker so that these classrooms aren’t interrupted by other ones. In lecture-like classes, the relationship between the teacher and student is lost. With an abundance of students, professors do not remember all students’ names and may never meet each student unless the student seeks help. In lecture halls, many professors use microphones to allow for all students, including those in the back rows to listen and take note of what they say. In a smaller class, if one sits in the front rows, the teacher interacts more with those students and expects them to pay attention compared to the far back rows. I agree with Noah’s comment that with online classes, your more disconnected from school, and interaction with other students and the professor. Kyle also pointed out that in a classroom you are more likely to talk to other people and get involved in school more by creating new friends.

Response to Sam Livorno (Week 2)

Our discussion group referred to the third prompt for our first writing project. We started with the questions, “How does a student befriend a professor?” and “Is it relatively easy or hard to establish a relationship with them?” We all agreed that it really depends on the students’ personality. If a student is very shy or introverted it would probably be harder for them to form a relationship with their professors. But, we also talked about how there is a gap between the student and the professor. The professor is the boss and it might be difficult for some students to look past that and see them as more of a friend that is trying to help them. The prompt provides a quote from Freire, that states, “Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction.” We all agreed with that statement and listed many different examples of how a student could overcome that barrier with their professor. Students can make small changes, such as sitting in the front of the class, making eye contact, and asking questions. The professors also help break that barrier by providing their students with office hours, where they them can ask questions one-on-one. Overall, there are many ways in befriending a professor and overcoming the “teacher-student contradiction”.

Laura McGroary

Amanda Jaing

Leah Schreffler

Sam Livorno

Response to Jakes Group

A good teacher to me is one who gets their students engaged with the class. Getting students involved is a good way to help them retain the information being taught. Teachers who stand and give information to memorize ultimately don’t leave their students with an understanding of the class. Teachers find a way to go through the motions of teaching to get through the course requirements, partially because they get paid the same either way. As long as a teacher gets the students good grades it doesn’t matter if its through memorizing or engaging. Freire also believes that teachers work through the motions. Students in a way are like prisoners; teachers give students set instructions and you must follow them or there are consequences. These tough guidelines is exactly what restricts kids from learning to their full potential, which Freire stresses heavily in his writing. If we are forced to follow the rules we cannot express our full potential.

Leader: Jake Heikkinin

Members: Makayla Medycki, Emily Foley, Mia Cicerone, Julia Digiogio, Gwen Jordan, Juliana Beristain, Maura Kelly.

Response to Bella

Participants- Sam, Gabe, Jenna, Lauren, Luke, Adam, Micheal, Bella, TJ, Brandon, Emily,

In todays discussion group, we discussed how “space” can effect a students education and study skills. We collectively compared pros and cons of West Chester’s campus and how the placement of the buildings can affect how and where students study and work. West Chester has rather small to medium sized classes which can help with 1 on 1 student teacher interactions. This can be helpful to get students more enthusiastic about class and participating. We also discussed the layout of campus and how academic buildings are separate from the housing buildings. The pros of this layout is that buildings of the same purpose are all close to each other. Although, a con to this layout is how far away these buildings are, like the library, from housing buildings. College students tend to study late at night and it’s inconvenient to have to walk that far all the way to the library at those late hours. Therefor, students resort to studying in their rooms or hall lounges.

Response to Isabella Bedore

Group names:

Sam, Lauren, Gabe, Adam, Michael, Bella, Luke, Tj, Emily , Brandon

In our discussion, we talked about how spacing mentally and physically affects our learning ability within our education at West Chester University. In the physical aspect we discussed the size of classrooms, most agreed with the notion that small traditional classrooms like the ones we were in at highschool are easier to learn. The bigger the classroom the harder it is to create a connection with your professor and ask questions. Most classes here at West Chester follow the traditional classroom which allows us to make more connections. Large lecture halls, on the other hand, allow students to zone out and feel helpless if they need help. Next, we talked about the layout of West Chester and how the classes and the dorms are far apart. We thought this was separating leisure from learning. You should study in a place similar to where you would take the test. Separating the dorms and classrooms allows students to study in a classroom setting. We also talked about the space between the age ratio of student to professor. The younger the professor, the easier it is to connect and learn from. Freire says that the banking system of education treats students as objects and that is what older professors treat us as. Older professors have been teaching the same way without changing it year to year. Students can relate more to younger professors due to similar habits.

Response to Jakes post

Mia C, Emily F, Makayla M, Julia D, Jake H, Michael L, Gwen J, Julianna B, Maura K

In our discussion we talked about what makes a good or bad teacher. There are many qualities that can determine a good or bad teacher. I think a good teacher will get to learn and understand his or her students. Everyone learns and comprehends things differently. If they are a visual learner, auditory learner, etc, the student and teacher success will most likely be much greater if that is communicated so adaptions can be made to fit everyones needs. Freire states that, “The teacher chooses the program content, and the students (who weren’t consulted) adapt to it,” which tends to be the case in most situations. Failure to adapt to a certain teaching style doesn’t have to mean that the student isn’t smart, it could mean that they simply cannot adjust to the teaching style.

Another thing that can draw the line between a great and terrible teacher is how they do their job. I’ve had classes where I had to teach myself the content due to laziness . They should try to engage students and make them understand what they are learning instead of having them memorize their powerpoint. Freire explains this when he says, “The teacher talks and the students listen-meekly,” which is exactly what happens in my opinion. They become part of a routine of memorize the content, take the test, and forget about it the second they hand it in.

Response to Jakes Post

Group: Michael Lindholn, Emily Foley, Makayla Medycki, Mia Citerane, Jake Heikkinen, Gwen Jordan, Julianna Benstein, Maura Kelly

  • In my discussion group we talked about how the difference between a good teacher and a bad teacher and referring that to Paulo Freire’s “The Banking Concept of Education“. We came up with the ideas that the connections students have with their teachers helps them want to learn in the class. Teachers who engage their students and focus on learning rather than lecturing help the student succeed. A bad teacher is one who ignores a students personal problems and requests. Some teachers dont treat students like humans and seem to not care because to them its just their job. We related this to Freire when he states that teachers are only there to do their job and how they focus on memorization more than the actual learning ability of a student. Freire also states that the teacher talks and the students listen which is an example of a bad teacher based on our discussion. In the end we agreed that we think teachers should enjoy teaching and want to see students succeed rather than it just being their job title.

Response to Nick

In responce to Nick

Nick and I both thought using the term “necrophilic’  was an extreme way of communicating this idea of the ‘banking concept of education’. Why would Freire choose to use this terminology when talking about education? In re-reading the preceding paragraphs, it made more sense to me. I still don’t think the term necrophilia is used correctly in this paper, within the definition that I found. If necrophilia is more defined by Fromm’s quote on page 3 then I can somewhat get behind his ideas on this. Fromm’s idea:  control in education kills. That the banking system of education is more ‘nourished by the love of death, not life’.

Freire says that the banking system of education treats the student as objects. Object’s don’t have life. Something that is dead doesn’t grow. A teacher who is so oppressively controlling kills all things creative and beautiful in their student. Freire goes on to say that this kind of oppressive domination ‘attempts to control thinking and action’. It reminds me of Germany in World war ll, when Hitler brainwashed the Germans to hate anyone who wasn’t purely German. Unfortunately, he succeeded. Did that mean that it was a good thing? Any type of education that destroys a love for learning, attempts to control the student’s ability to reason and think deeply, only benefits the teachers and school, and creates automatons is, in my opinion,  a deeply failed education system. 

Nick

Ruthie

Response to Caitlin Mangini

Caitlin Mangini, Amanda Regan, Sarah Veneziali,Seamus Corkery, Sabrina Lindley, Haley Clark, Olivia Vearling, Ava Hill, and Meghan Kidd

This week the discussion group I participated in focused on the fact that students are just supposed to consume information from teachers and be able to spit out the answer on demand. I agree with this statement, when it relates to the student and teacher relationship. Teachers tend to randomly call on students during class and expect them to answer their question immediately. Many teachers usually use some type of powerpoint to center their class around. During these powerpoint, teachers usually will call on students unexpectedly, without warning, and expect them to voice out an answer. It is very difficult for students to do this even when they are paying attention. Sometimes nerves or fear of embarrassment takes place and the student is left upset. I believe that if students have to be put through this kind of treatment, teachers also should be. Often times when students have questions the teachers will exclaim that they will get back to them. This is unfair and should be eliminated. No one should be told that they need to give an answer immediately after receiving a question on command.

Response to Space and Learning

Leader Bella 

Followers Luke Gabe Mike Sam Jenna Adam lauren  Emily Brandon TJ 

How space impacts our learning capabilities. Both in our brain and our environment. With the West Chester campus we are able to talk to our teachers one on one. Learning is different for everyone and our earning environment also effects people different. Most people in the discussion group prefer the traditional smaller, more high school like classroom and they also prefer young teachers because we feel we are able to connect more with them and they understand us more. We find that lectures tend to go off topic and it does not cover the initial question that was asked. When we look at a person physical “space” it also varies in that someone can be able to focus longer then another and also people can study longer and be able to intake information more than another. We see that some people do work better when they are comfortable such as their dorms or in a common area and others prefer the structure of being in a classroom  to learn and retain their information.

Response to Jake Heikkinin

In our discussion we talk about the differences between the believe of a good teacher, and bad teacher. Most 0f the time the failure of a student, is responsibility of the teacher. But what really is for students the meaning of learning from a good teacher.When teachers connect with their students and engaged with them, it makes more easy for a class to flow and have students connect on what the teacher is talking about, a good teacher makes their students to visualize what they are learning and give examples of their own in order to maker sure the students understand what he wants the student to get. In my opinion I feel supported by my teachers when they have available office hours for students in case I did not understand something on class, or if I need help for projects or assignments.Most of good teachers care about what they do in class and why they are doing it so their students get independent in order to learn their material. We also talk about what are the characteristics of a bad teacher. When teachers are not patient with their students, they only teach what they have to teach in order to get paid, they expect students to learn their method of teaching in order to learn, they look ways that are easy to them in order to teach but not for students in order to learn, they embarrasses their students in class making them feel less. This connects to Freire in most of his ideas of a bad teacher, teachers expect students to learn the way they teach, and students do not receive the enough help they need.

Group: Makayla Medycki, Emily Foley, Julia Digiogio, Michael Lindholn, Gwen Jordan, Maura Kelly

Response to Discussion Group Week 2: Topic of Placement in a Classroom & Spacing

Leader: Noah Heslop Others: Nick Passis, Bella Dibasquale, Kyle Owens, Muhammad Rabi, Donny Lessing, Haley Myers, and Sean Redding

In this group we talked about how the structure of a classroom with all chairs facing front, in rows, and the teacher’s desk up front creates a sense of uniform and togetherness in a classroom. This allows each student to have the same opportunity to learn the same way equally. This style of classroom also makes the students look like robots who must sit in a certain way and do everything the way the teacher wants. We also talked about the spacing between classrooms and how it allows students to focus on one topic at a time and not have distractions from other classes. This also makes a more comfortable environment for students to learn in when it is a small separated classroom. This idea lead to the discussion of how the connection with a teacher is different in small classrooms vs. a large lecture. In a smaller classroom your teacher is more likely to actually know your name and engage in conversation with you whereas in a large lecture hall most teachers don’t even know their student’s names. There was brief discussion about online classes and we basically just summed up that online classes are a huge disconnect from any type of relationship or social interaction and are very formal.

Discussion post week 2, Topic of Space in the classroom

Participants: Isabella (Organizer), Lauren, Luke, Mike, Sam, Adam, Jenna, Tj, Brandon, Emily, Gabe (myself)

The topic for the morning was the metaphorical and physical ideas behind the space in the classroom. The first thing I had noticed right off the bat was the organization of the setup we had made, where Isabella was projecting towards the rest of us. While this is minimal as it served as a practical means of getting ideas out to the group it’s evident that the way we are spaced within the classroom will typically be applied to the outside environment in situations like this. The second topic that was prominent was the areas in which studying was most effective, the focal point (Which was decided among the group) was that lounges often provide the best habitat for study time. During this discussion there was a pivot, where the group discussed the styles of classrooms, for instance lectures and smaller rooms and the effects they have on people. While the younger teachers are more linked as the age gap is smaller and therefore the likelihood of progressive nature is higher, older teachers are far more likely to hold their own style as they’ve found it to be the best method, despite the disconnect from the students. An example the group had talked over was FYE, the issues revolved around the size of the class, the disconnect between the lecturers and the lectured, and the lack of focus on main ideas discussed, and as a result of these issues many feel that the space between the teachers and fellow students render the class useless.

Discussion group week 2

In our discussion group we talked about the importance of spacing in a classroom and how it has affected each of us individually. Spacing greatly affects how students feel in a classroom and the interactions they make. The amount of seats in a classroom plays a big factor in how well each student knows their professor. We agreed in lecture halls with over 100 students it is much easier to become sidetracked, and less engaged. When in small classroom settings students feel more focused and motivated. In a smaller class size students are much more likely to reach out for help if needed. Many of us prefer smaller classroom settings for this reason. We also discussed how the seats are all set up the same which gives each student a similar point of view. However we agreed students in the back of the room find it much easier to become distracted, while students in the front are motivated to focus. Lastly in our discussion we talked about online classes. The majority agreed it is more beneficial to have a professor in the room with you. I personally find it easier to become less engaged in an online class. Overall classroom spacing greatly affects how we learn.

Kyle O ,Noah H, Riley, Nick p, Donny L, Haley M, Sean 
Bella d, Muhhammad rabi 

Leader- Noah


Response to Jake

What makes a teacher is when the teacher engages with the students and give the students independence. When teachers give examples to the students and fully explains them to the students. I feel that when teachers connect to the students the students understand the material more. What makes a teacher bad is that they are ignorant sometimes to problems going on in the students life. They don’t always understand the problems going on in the students life. They make the students memorize the information instead of fully teaching it and that can confuse the students because they don’t always understand the information in the books fully. This connects to Freire by saying that student don’t always get the help they need when doing their work and understanding. Students sometimes can over exaggerate the teachers not doing their work by just being lazy but teachers can sometimes not explain fully the material. 

Leader: Jake Heikkinin 

Group: Makayla Medycki, Emily Foley, Mia Citerone, Julia Digiogio, Michael Lindholn, Gwen Jordan, Julianna Beristain

Discussion Group 2

              In our discussion group we talked about Friere’s quote “The truth is, however, that the oppressed are not “marginals,” are not people living “outside” society. They have always been “inside”—inside the structure which made them “beings for others.” From this we got that oppression plays a big role in our society and that their needs to be a change to stop this. Their needs to be more for the oppressed to do so that they can become more a part of society. Jake connected to Friere’s quote by talking about the foundation that he is apart of, this foundation helps children in Chester through back to school giveaways and other things to help out. We hear all the time how kids in areas such as Chester to make it out of their poor situation, it is hard for them to make something out of their lives when they come for nothing. Their needs to be something  that our society can do to make it easier for them to make something out of their lives.

David H

Gabby L

Jason R

Maddy b

Jake D

Timothy D

css.php