Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
September 2019 – Page 7 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Response to Mackenzie

Group: Luke, Dana, Jenna, Lauren, Mackenzie, Nick, Noah, Bella, Kira

Our group talked about how the quote, “Here, no one teaches another, nor is anyone selftaught. People teach each other…” related to our educational system. We believed that our education system was mostly focused on memorizing information to later use for a test. We said that in order for someone to learn, they have to tell their ideas to others and instead of the listener learning from them, the speaker is becoming more knowledgeable. By talking to someone you are able to read what you are going to say, actually say what you are reading, and then hear it. You are taking in information three different ways just by reading your thoughts to someone else. In order for someone to gain more knowledge, they should also try and connect to what they are speaking about to something that they care about. Mackenzie brought up that when you are in Spanish class and have to give a presentation, you do not learn what you are going to say, you are merely memorizing it. By connecting it to something you care about, the information will be more meaningful.

Writing Project 1 Topic Proposal

Topic: Topic 1 (podcast)

Team: Lauren Beccaria, Sami Kakar, Jeffrey Biancaniello

Working Thesis: There is pronounced significance as to how West Chester University campus is spatially arranged; however, there is a myriad of solutions to enhance the learning and living environment to best help learners to succeed.

Two quotes from Freire to back up our Thesis:

Quote 1: “A deepened consciousness of their situation leads people to apprehend that situation as an historical reality susceptible of transformation. Resignation gives way to the drive for transformation and inquiry, over which men feel themselves to be in control. If people, as historical beings necessarily engaged with other people in a movement of inquiry, did not control that movement, it would be (and is) a violation of their humanity. Any situation in which some individuals prevent others from engaging in the process of inquiry is one of violence. The means used are not important; to alienate human beings from their own decision-making is to change them into objects.”

Quote 2: “This movement of inquiry must be directed towards humanization— the people’s historical vocation. The pursuit of full humanity, however, cannot be carried out in isolation or individualism, but only in fellowship and solidarity; therefore it cannot unfold in the antagonistic relations between oppressors and oppressed. No one can be authentically human while he prevents others from being so.”

Response to Bella

In the discussion group I attended we talked about how you can only teach someone if they are trying to teach you while in fact they are teaching themselves.  People learn from real world experiences. They do not learn in the classroom. Speaking and communication is one of the most important aspects of learning so it would only make sense that when you are doing the speaking that you are the one learning.  Someone in the group made a good point about how teachers are the students and the students are the teachers because the teachers are the only one speaking and talking about the information. It would seem that with this view on teaching that the roles of the classroom are switched drastically.  In the end, everyone learns differently and in their own way. This style of learning while teaching could work for one person but hurt another.

Group members: Amanda, Bella, David, Gwen, John,Mia, Emily, Julia, Maura

Writing Project 1: project proposal

Topic Proposal: Topic 3

Team Selection: Just Ruthie Lohmann

Working Thesis: An educator and student are on the same path to a life-long acquisition of knowledge and understanding through discovery and rediscovery of information as it relates to their own distinct experiences and how this new perceived awareness relates to the world in which they live.

Two Quotes from Freire to back up my Thesis:

1) “The problem- posing method does not dichotomize the activity of the teacher-student: she is not “cognitive” at one point and “narrative” at another. She is always “cognitive,” whether preparing a project or engaging in dialogue with the students. He does not regard cognizable objects as his private property, but as the object of reflection by himself and the student. In this way, the problem-posing educator constantly re-forms his refections in the refection of the students. The students- no longer docile listeners-are now critical co-investigators in dialogue with the teacher. The teacher presents the material to the student for their consideration, and re-considers her earlier considerations as the students express their own. The role of the problem-posing educator is to create, together with the student , the conditions under which knowledge at the level of doxa is superseded by true knowledge, at the level of logos.”

2) “Problem- posing education affirms men and women as being in the process of becoming- as unfinished, uncompleted beings in and with a likewise unfinished reality. Indeed, in contrast to other animals who are unfinished, but not historical, people know themselves be unfinished; they are aware of their incompletion. In this incompletion and this awareness lie the very roots of education as an exclusively human manifestation. The unfinished character of humans beings and the transformational character of reality necessitates that education be an ongoing activity.”

Response to Bella

Group Members:Emily Foley, Bella Diasquale, Gwen Jordan, Maura Kelly, Makayla Medycki, Mia. Cieteroni, Ava Hill, Amanda Reagan, John Comperson, David Heffron, Ethan Stein, Liv.

Discussion: In my discussion group we discussed mostly on the topic that no one teaches except for teaching themselves. They are based on learning from experience, and the activities and experiences they go through. When teaching other people you gain a personal advantage to new ideas and learning but the other person is not obtaining the same knowledge. Everyone has a different way of learning and viewing things differently so teaching one way to a group of people will not teach anyone anything. Everyone understands things differently so they will not understand the way you do. We also talked about how engaging in a conversation will teach yourselves. In our discussion group we all seemed to agree on our ideas and applied them to our real lives and how we all actually do have different learning ways and how weird it is in classrooms. The difference in everyones interpretations and views is very interesting and cool to think about

Discussion week 3

Writing discussion group

Nick- Leader 

Followers Kyle, Abbey, Mimi, TJ, Adam

Students usually are talked at instead of taught. For most cases students teach themselves opposed to learning from the teachers. Teachers should not only try to inform students on the content but also be open to learning from the students themselves. Communicating with your peers is a better way to learn because if they are talking to each other then they are able to help other comprehend the content and make sure everyone understands. Students learn and understand differently so if they are struggling in class then they are able to ask their peers outside of class for assistants. By students helping students we not only learn the co tent but we also learn how to help each other. Students also help teachers by asking questions and by also shedding light on topics that teachers are unknowing about. Most teachers do not know a lot of information on technology so we as a younger generation are able to assist them in the transition towards a more technologically advanced future.

Writing project, step one

Gabe Jasinski

I’ll be working alone on this assignment, making the choice to research the possibilities of topic number two, the Student power.

The idea that students in the collective are essentially slaves to the classrooms and teachers that inhabit them are merely scratching of the surface, to truly delve into the idea of power in the students we must first look at how students are perceived in society both on a historical and contemporary level.

Quotable sections:

  1. The capability of banking education to minimize or annul the students’ creative power and to stimulate their credulity serves the interests of the oppressors, who care neither to have the world revealed nor to see it transformed. The oppressors use their “humanitarianism” to preserve a profitable situation. Thus they react almost instinctively against any experiment in education which stimulates the critical faculties and is not content with a partial view of reality but always seeks out the ties which link one point to another and one problem to another
  2. Indeed, the interests of the oppressors lie in “changing the consciousness of the oppressed, not the situation which oppresses them”; for the more the oppressed can be led to adapt to that situation, the more easily they can be dominated. To achieve this end, the oppressors use the banking concept of education in conjunction with a paternalistic social action apparatus, within which the oppressed receive the euphemistic title of “welfare recipients.” They are treated as individual cases, as marginal persons who deviate from the general configuration of a “good, organized, and just” society. The oppressed are regarded as the pathology of the healthy society, which must therefore adjust these “incompetent and lazy” folk to its own patterns by changing their mentality. These marginals need to be “integrated,” “incorporated” into the healthy society that they have “forsaken.”

Response to Brandon

group members: Sam Weitzel, Sam Livoreno, Gabe, Cait, Sara , Seamus, David, Haley, Katherine, and Amanda (me)

In my third week of discussion, we talked about if we agree with Paulo Freire’s ideologies about how people learn in general. The discussion group brought our individual opinion towards the concept. We came to the conclusion that Freire’s writing contradicted himself. Stating that individual can not be self-taught or taught my someone else. We all came to the disagreement of his belief in learning. I personally believe that people can learn from others teaching and individual experience. By getting taught by others, I learn the concept and their perspective. All in all, I believe everyone’s way of learning is different. Some might be better from getting taught by another person and others might think it’s easier to teach themselves.

Response to Jason R. (Week 3)

Leader: Jason R.

Followers: Jake H, Lila S, Juiliana B, Timothy D, Riley B, Maddie B, Robby, Ruthie L, Sean R, Nick P, Christian J, Micheal R, Jake D, Gabby L

This week during our discussion group we had a large number of students show up, probably because it was the only time that worked for most people. We discussed the differences between banking education and the problem- posing education and the strengths and weaknesses between the two. The majority of people agreed that the banking concept of education does not work for us and especially me. I believe that Friere made some good points but i don’t obviously agree with everything he said. I feel the best learning happens outside of the classroom and in the real world, but an education is still important. People stare at books too much and life passes them by when they should be outside learning things through life and get educated from proffesors in real life situations that will help them in todays society, not 1000 years ago’s society.

Response to Sam

Laura Mcgroary, Mike Tresoikas, Meghan Kidd, Sam Pawluczyk – Leader

There is always a debate between how someone can learn and consume more information, whether it be in the classroom or outside in the real world. Today our discussion group agreed that learning from real life experiences is more valuable than sitting in the classroom and being told to memorize and retain specific information. The benefits of learning from real life experiences include many ideas. For example, when dealing with someone’s own experiences they have the ability to make mistakes and then at some point, they have the ability to change their approach and correct their mistake. Another huge benefit includes hands on learning. Many people are able to consume or information if they are doing it themselves, as opposed to visual learning. Finally, in classroom settings not everyone has the ability to participate. Some people are quiet and shy and therefore will not raise their hands or have the confidence to answer a question. In contrast, if they were dealing with their lives and a problem formed, they would be able to handle it as they please. It makes more sense to learn from real life experiences, rather than in the classroom.

Response to Jason

Jason R
Juliana B
Timothy T
Riley B
Maddie B
Mahammad R 
Ruthie L
Jake H
Sean R
Nick P
Christian P
Michael R
Jake D
Gabby L
Leah S

Today we discussed whether the banking system of education or the problem-posing method of education is more effective for educating humans. We all seemed to agree at the end that the problem-posing method is a much more effective way to educate. We talked about how high school methods of education are just like the general education requirements for college.  We talked about how this posed a problem for most of us. We sat through high school being filled with information to memorize. We memorized this information so that we could pass tests. Then we forgot the information as soon the tests were done. What is the purpose of memorizing information we are soon to forget? Seeing how we can apply what we are being taught to our lives or see its importance would help us take an interest in the content- thus helping us to retain that information.  General education classes we are required to take in college can feel the same way. If feels like a waste of money when there is a disconnect as to why we are learning what we are learning, especially if it has nothing to do with our field of study. Making those personal real-world connections can really help us learn. We are not robots, created to learn information so that we can just work a job, as one of the students eloquently said today. Quality of living life after all our learning plummets, if that is the end goal. 

Topic Proposal: Ava Hill

Topic Selection: Student Power

Team Selection: Myself

Thesis: Freire recognizes that the banking concept of education won’t work, the solution isn’t the teacher but the student’s power to receive their freedom. Here at West Chester University students must gain this freedom through Freire’s problem-posing education by engaging in group projects to emphasize communication as well as using information to learn that is important to their own reality.

2 Quotes: 1. “Here, no one teaches another, nor is anyone self-taught. People teach each other, mediated by the world, by the coginazable objects which in banking education are ‘owned’ by the teacher” 2. “Students, as they are increasingly posed with problems relating to themselves in the world and with the world, will feel increasingly challenged and obliged to respond to their challenge.” 3. ” Authentic thinking thinking that is concerned with reality, does not take place in ivory tower isolation, but only in communication.”

response to Brandon

david macmullen, seamus corkey, haley clark, sam livoreno, sarah veneziale, brandon vahal, gabe jasinski, sam weitzel, amanda, katherine

In this discussion on Thursday, we talked about of Freire believes there is only one way of teaching. This way is the teacher talks and the students listen. We all agree with this in that it is a way to teach, but it isn’t the only way. There are many more ways to teach and to learn, such as reading a textbook, using partners, or doing research. Every student learns differently and every teacher teaches differently. We also talked about what was due in class on Monday. We talked about the writing topic proposals and if we were using partners, what topic we were doing, etc. We talked about the project and helped each other out on the topic selections and gave each other ideas on what to write about. We decided to help each other in explaining the prompts and working through Freire’s work to better understand.

Response to Jason

Jason R
Juliana B
Timothy T
Riley B
Maddie B
Mahammad R
Ruthie L
Jake H
Sean R
Nick P
Christian P
Michael R
Jake D
Gabby L
Leah S

Our discussion was about Banking education and problem posing. We talked about which type of education is best for students and we all agreed that problem posing is the only option. I think problem posing is the only efficient way of learning because a student comprehends the information instead of memorizing it. A person cannot learn if a person is filling them with information like a robot. There is only so much a person can remember and when the class is for an entire year, that is so much time wasted if they do not take anything from it. Banking method can hurt someone’s education more than it can help it. In high school, education was mostly memorization. In college, some of the general education classes are not necessary for one’s specific major and most people do not learn or comprehend anything from it. This is a waste of time and money for the student. Learning is about comprehension and understanding, not jamming everything into your brain and hoping you remember everything. Banking is a concept that should not exist. I wish my high school taught me to comprehend and understand information because I feel that I am behind some people because all I have ever learned is memorization.

Response to Bella

Leader: Bella D

Followers: Maura Kelly, Gwen Jordan, Mia Citerone, Emily Foley, Ava Hill, John C, Makayla M, Ethan S, David H, Julia G, Liv V

In our discussion we talked about the quote “Here no one teachers another, nor is anyone taught. People teach each other.” We talked about how one can not just casually give knowledge to someone because they won’t understand it if you are just throwing it all at them. We also discussed that you have to experience things in order to gain knowledge of it. This quote really focuses on the fact that you learn more from teaching others than you do from being taught. Each person has a different way of learning, so we can’t expect people to understand things the same way. Engaging in conversation is a crucial way of teaching because communication is the key to teaching. Whether people teach themselves, or others, it is different for every person to process and learn the information, so communication is key to understanding what is being taught.

Response to Jason Riberio

In our group we talk about the difference of banking education and the problem that teachers work on specific topics. We lead that banking concept is a waste of time for students in order to learn and that sometimes this leads them to don’t get a good job they had been working all the time in college. We also talk about that students should choose their classes in order for them to learn, in order to graduate and a field that a student have pick, there is so many additional classes that most of the students don’t feel is necessary.The problem focuses more in students critical thinking and is that teachers have to make students engage in order for them to learn. Even though that everybody thinks they learn on class, the true is that students don’t feel engage, and they don’t have the desire to practice it by their own, and they end up failing and not learning. The problem posting method is better than the banking concept.

Group: Jason R, Lia S, Timothy D , Riley B, Maddie B, Ruthie L, Jake H, Sean R, Nick P, Christian J , Michael R ,Jake D , Gabby L.

discussion group 3

David H

Bella d

Amanda r

Maura k

Ethan s

Ava h

Gwen j

Mia c

John a

Emily f

In our discussion group we talked about the way that Freire says is best for people learn and engage with topics. You can take your knowledge and teach it to someone, and it must relate to them for you to be able to learn personally. When people give information to you, you will not be able to just learn off that, and you will not be able to learn by teaching to people who don’t want to hear what you are saying and aren’t engaging. No one can learn from people lecturing or even being taught one on one, nor can anyone teach themselves anything on their own. There has to be two things for learning to occur, both another person for you to engage with and a about, a topic that is engaging both to you and the person whom you are engaging with.

Discussion Group Week 3: Topic of difference between banking education and problem posing education

Leader: Jason R Others: Liya S, Juliana B, Timothy D, Riley B, Maddie B, Ruthie L, Jake H, Sean R, Nick P, Christian J, Michael R, Jake D, Gabby L, Muhammad R 

In this discussion group we talked about how most people are forced to take classes that they don’t want and or have no interest in. We talked about how this creates a forced learning style and makes people not want to go to school. We also said that people should be able to choose what classes they want to take since they are paying for their education. This goes along with the banking education idea. We agreed that the problem posing education was better than the banking education. This is because the problem posing education focuses more on the student’s critical thinking which is better than the student just being taught at and having no opinion. In banking education the student’s thoughts are not considered. This is not a good way to get an education because you have no thoughts or say in how you learn and what you learn. That’s the difference between the banking education and problem posing education.

Jason R, Liya S, Juliana B, Timothy Domanowski, Riley B, Maddie E, Mohamad R, Ruthie L, Jake H, Saen R, Nick P, Christian j, Micheal R, Jake D, Gabby L,

Difference between the Banking education and Problem posing education.

The banking of education is not a good system because of how passive you are and your not actually learning you are just temporarily storing information. High school was mostly the banking education model with the teacher simply teaching so you can do good on the next test which the information doesn’t last as long as soon as the test is done and you don’t need it anymore the same goes for classes in college that you are only taking for credits not because you actually want to learn the topic. An example given was an accounting major taking a history classes because you need to and everything in class that was learned will quickly leave your brain ounce the class is over and the class was basically a waste of your time. The problem posing method is better because it makes students more engaged in the topic but the problem of students not caring is still there.

Response to Jason

Jason R, Liz s, Ju B, Timothy D, riley B, Maddie B, ruthie L, Jake h, Sean R, nick P, Christian j, Micheal R, jake D, Muh R

In our discussion group we will talk about the differences between banking education and problem-posing education. We also discussed the strengths and weaknesses between the two. The banking education system is not efficient because of how passive you are and you potentially aren’t actually learning. In high school the banking education was mainly model that the teacher taught you to do good on the test less of learning the actual information. You memorize everything your teacher taught you, use it for the test, and then all the information you retained is gone. We talked about how most people are forced to take classes and go to college that they really don’t want to be at and learn. This causes a forced learning style, making not want to go to school and get an educational. This is better then the banking education method. Problem Posing education is getting students to do more and get involved in a learning environment. Banking education is when the teacher just talks and is teaching you while ur sitting in a classroom, and your supposed to obtain all the information the professor talks about. Problem posing forces students to use critical thinking and talking about in groups with other peers.

css.php