Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Responses – Page 24 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Respnose to Meghan Kidd

Group: Samantha, Meghan

In our discussion group we talked and compared Percy to Freire and how both have different perspectives on learning. We stated how Percy wants us to learn outside the classroom and how Freire explains the interaction of students, teachers and the learning process. As Percy references, he wants us to learn outside the classroom, learning from experiences and taking things in while in the moment. Learning to take a moment to regroup to remember what you learned is an important process because realizing it is very important because you can get mixed up in your learning process and misunderstand everything your learning.  As Freire references, he wants us to learn in the classroom through teachings. Through both of these people, all of us in the group realize that we can learn from different ways depending on every person, but as students we don’t always realize the different ways to learn. These two writers help us realize how many different ways there are to learn in life.

Response to Maddie

Group Members: Haley, Amanda, Leah, Maddie

In our discussion group we discussed shortcuts and how Walker Percy perceives them in “The Loss of the Creature.” We talked about how taking shortcuts in life can be detrimental to your future depending on the case of the shortcut that you are taking. People that take shortcuts, or the easier way tend to not be as motivated as others, which is not a good thing. This happens frequently in education when students try to take shortcuts in their learning. The students are just playing themselves. If they do not learn the entirety of the information that they need they will fall behind and hinder their own ability to do well. Taking shortcuts is not always a bad thing though. There can be instances when it does not have a bad consequence on you. Overall, taking shortcuts in education is not something that people should take lightly and if people decide to take on that path it can ruin their learning opportunities.

Discussion Group 5

Timothy Domanowski, Kyle Owens, Bella B, Jake D, Kenzie Neiderer, Jason Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian Galilea, David Heffron, Joshua Rogers, Muhammad Rabi, Jake Heikkinen, Sean Redding, Tyler Evans,  Sam Livorno

The questions was on how to learn effectively which I suggested that you must do more then memorize the answers and you need to know how to get the answer. I compared it to how I study for math classes in which I try to solve a problem by only being able to check if I got it right and if I need help I look up how to do the question. Some other ideas people came up with was Memorization isn’t effective, we wind up making more work for ourselves Teachers using Power point makes it easier for the professors and harder for students, Shortcuts don’t allow for creativity, and change is a creative process. Googling the answers to homework is easier but won’t help you on the test later. Simply memorizing is not enough for effective learning and you yourself need to be teaching yourself.

Response to Laura McGroary

Group: Donny Lessin, Laura McGroary, Kira Aves, Brandon

In this discussion group we acknowledged the similarities and differences between Freire and Percy. Both writers believe teaching beyond talking, and think learning happens when people learn through visuals and other connections. In frieres essay, he argues that students are presented with new information in such a way that students don’t link a connection to make it meaningful or important. In a similar way, Percy presents the same argument by using the Grand Canyon comparison. He instigates that anyone who visits the Grand Canyon that has background knowledge of the land through post cards or reviews online defeats the purpose of seeing it in person, making the visit meaningless. Both students and tourists take in everything they hear and are told but don’t comprehend the significance of what’s being addressed.  We found as a group that Freire and Percy differ by the means of creating life experiences. Freire suggests to going out and seeking connects helps better learning while Percy suggests that going out and creating an experience doesn’t better learning since from having contextual knowledge of the experience completely the defeats the purpose of making a real-life connection for learning to happen.

Writing Project 2

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ho8dS8hHqsNYG15P6u8oOVwF8lcOLqK5IKOhxYd3Kmc/edit?usp=sharing

Topic: 2; Learning outside the classroom

Team: Just me 

Thesis:  Students constantly find themselves in the predicament in that the information presented in class isn’t clearly comprehended. Everyone learns differently whether students learn visually, auditorily, or physically. To accommodate for all learners, education outside the classroom will help students grasp complex information presented in class to improve their comprehension of their major and minors of study. 

Way 1: Tutoring

Students can learn outside the classroom by seeking a tutor. Tutors help to review class concepts to clear up any confusion in the classroom. Whether in a small group tutoring group or 1 on 1 help, students are able to ask questions they didn’t present to the teacher in class or ask for reclassification of certain topics. Tutoring is a great way to teach students study skills by forcing students to review their notes after class. 

Way 2: Field trips/studying abroad

Students enter classrooms everyday and by freire’s banking concept of education, they are expected to understand the given deposits of information by teachers to then store it for memorization for tests. Percy suggests learning is strongest when one creates new experiences based on their curiosity. By studying abroad or going on field trips, students escape the classic classroom experience and adventure into the unknown experiences to further their learning. Studying abroad provides real-world awareness of the topic at hand allowing the individual to make connections with their studies.

Way 3: Discussion groups

Way 4: Internships

  • Work experience is an important part of education for one’ career of choice

Quote 1: “Our complex friend stands behind his fellow tourists at the Bright Angel Lodge and sees the canyon through them and their predicament, their picture taking and busy disregard. In a sense, he exploits his fellow tourists; he stands on their shoulders to see the canyon” (Percy 1).

Quote 2:  “It is given expression by their repeated exclamations that “this is too good to be true,” and by their anxiety that it may not prove to be so perfect” (Percy 3).

Quote 3: “Does this mean that we should get rid of museums? No, but it means that the sightseer should be prepared to enter into a struggle to recover a sight from a museum” (Percy 6).

Response to Nik

Group members: Amanda, Seamus, Sarah

In this weeks discussion our small group talked about the second topic for this project. Topic two talks about what could happen outside of the classrooms here at WCU to support student learning. Our group thought that students should take advantage of all that is offered outside of the classroom. One example we came up with would be the tutoring center. The tutoring center provides students with a place to take initiative of their own learning and spend a couple hours a week to further their education and understand more about a class or topic. Students could also join clubs and study groups to keep themselves busy and prepared for all their classes. If students keep themselves busy with tutoring, clubs and study groups, that is more time being productive and getting ahead on work and studying.

Response to Shawn

Kyle Owens, Bella B, Jake D, Kenzie Neiderer, Jason, Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian Galilea, David Heffron, Joshua Rogers, Muhammad Rabi, Jake Heikkinen, Sean Redding, Tyler E, Nick,Timothy Domanowski, Sam Livorno

In our discussion on Friday, we talked about the shortcuts in life that we tend to take. Taking the easier route always sounds like a better option, but at times can be a very problematic decision in the end. For instance, I tend to rely heavily on a website called symbolab, which solves problems for my math class. This website should be utilized by me in order to help as a complimentary role that can be used as a way to check my answers, rather than solving them for me. When teachers teach, they tend to use powerpoint a lot. Powerpoints filled with long arrays of information are easier for the teacher, but very difficult for students taking notes when the teacher goes by the slides in a very quick manner. Shortcuts are rarely effective, and a large proportion of the time lowers the standard of quality of the finished product. We all agreed that in the end, when shortcuts are taken by teachers or professors there is no room for creativity and it can hurt the students in their performances.

Response to Maddie

Group: Amanda,John,Haley

In my discussion group we discussed the topic should a person take a shortcut or not? my answer to this is simple I believe that shortcuts are good things at certain standards. Cheating on a test for example would not be a good shortcut because it will not only get you in trouble but is also a sign that you are neglecting your studies for something else. A good type of shortcut in my opinion would be something that can benefit you in a situation but should not harm someone or take away someone advantages against you in a certain situation. Shortcuts are good things if you are doing them properly do not take shortcuts to just get something over with only take shortcuts if it benefits you in a proper way and follows the rules

Topic 1

Team: Samantha Pawluczyk and Meghan Kidd

Thesis: Arts, Ethics, Humanities, and several others are all required and have the same end goal of earning a diploma after a long duration of education at West Chester University.

Every individual at WCU has to take classes that do not retain to their major in any way.
Everyone is required to spend more money than they need to in order to take classes that do not pertain to their end goal. It only takes roughly 40-60 credits to obtain a diploma, but every student has to take on average 125 credits to graduate.

2 quotes:

“The sightseer may be aware that something is wrong. He may simply be bored; or he may be conscious of the difficulty: that the great thing yawning at his feet somehow eludes him.” It’s up to us to make the most of our education so we get out as much as we put in.
“ For example, after a lifetime of avoiding the beaten track and guided tours, a man may deliberately seek out the most beaten track of all, the most commonplace tour imaginable: he may visit the canyon by a Greyhound tour in the company of a party from Terre Haute—just as a man who has lived in New York all his life may visit the Statue of Liberty.”

Response to Laura

In this week’s discussion group, we talked about the similarities and differences between Percy and Freire, more specifically about their views on the education system.

Overall, there were more similarities than differences between the two scholars. Some of the similarities we talked about had to do with the fact that when we are taught or someone is teaching, no one is truly learning anything. With Percy’s view, however, his has more to do with real life experiences than learning in a classroom. Percy thinks we aren’t living in the moment and that it’s something we need to do more of. Another similarity would be that when information is presented or experienced with our own eyes, it isn’t as meaningful.

The only difference we discussed was that while they both think we, the learners, need to go out and learn for ourselves with others and our surroundings, Percy thinks that our experiences aren’t fully learned because we weren’t the first ones to experience it.

Members: Laura, Hailey, Donny, and Brandon

Project 2 Topic Proposal

Topic: Education Beyond the Major

Team: Myself

Thesis: Learning things outside of a specific major are very important. Education beyond the major helps students such as building necessary life skills, discovering how the student learns…

Supporting Ideas: “It is only the rarest student who knows that the sonnet must be salvaged from the package”(Percy 4)

“They have in common the stratagem of avoiding the educator’s direct presentation of the object as a lesson to be learned and restoring access to sonnet and dogfish as beings to be known, reasserting the sovereignty of knower over known”(Percy 5)

Response to Gabby

Group members: Kyle Owens, Bella B, Jake D, Kenzie Neiderer, Jason Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian Galilea, David Heffron, Muhammad Rabi, Jake Heikkinen, Sean Redding, Tyler E, Nick,Timothy Domanowski, Sam Livorno 

On Thursday, I attended a large discussion group where we talked about the topic of the “beaten path” discussed by Percy. The group talked about different situations where someone taking shortcuts can have both positive and negative consequences. We believe that a lot of people take these shortcuts and expect the best results from their actions. For example, a student who cheats on a test expects that cheating is a good thing because it helps him get a better grade. This may be true, however, the student is cheating himself by not actually learning anything so the student is really hurting themselves. When connecting this to Percy and education, we all agreed that when shortcuts are taken by teachers or professors there is no room for creativity which hurts the students.

discussion group

Group members: David H, Kyle O, Bella B, Jake D, Kenzie N, Jason R, Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian G, Joshua R, Muhammad R, Jake H, Sean R, Tyler E, Nick, Timothy D, Sam L

In our discussion group we talked about “The loss of the Creature” by Percy and how people take the “beaten track” and what is both good and bad about doing so. Taking shortcuts can sometimes seem like the easy way out of things but much bad can come from this like when people just copy homework and notes from others and then do bad on tests it is because they tried taking the easy way putting in less work but this leads to poor results in the end. Or on the other hand sometimes professors will just lecture off of the same PowerPoints because that is the easy way out for them but the outcome of that is students doing poor in the class and not gaining anything from the class. By taken the beaten path, less is gained from the experience and less creativity is allowed which is essential to be more open minded and learn more.

Response to Maddie

group: Amanda, John, Haley

In this discussion, we discussed shortcuts. The question was should a person take a shortcut or should they not? We talked about how taking shortcuts are only cheating yourself. We talked about certain instances where shortcuts are beneficial and are not as big of a deal. We discussed how taking shortcuts can affect a person, especially when it comes to education. Creating in school and taking the easy way out to have a good great will only affect you in the future. You will not be prepared as much as the other students are. If everyone were to take shortcuts, they would not be shortcuts anymore. Towards the end of the discussion, we discussed the project and talked about the different topics.

Responce to Julia D

Mia Citerone

Julia Digiorgio

Ava Hill

In our discussion, we analyzed the topic that an educator cannot save learning. Percy describes how teachers cannot teach you anything. It is all up to the student. Teachers are there to push you along whereas they cannot force you to learn or retain information. That is up to the student. Freire also hits on this point when he says no one teaches another. Students and people learn through experience. They need to be engaged by these experiences to get the full learning experience to be what they imagined. Balance is important through this because not only does it allow students to learn how they want, but also what they want. Percy talks about how preconceived ideas of learning can have a negative impact on the information they retain. The students have. To go out and learn for themselves. This is why the educator cannot save learning. The student has to do their part as well.

Project 2 Proposal

David,Seamus,Haley

Effective Writing

Professor Cream

10/27/19

Topic Proposal

Team Selection: David MacMullen

Topic Selection: Learning Outside the Classroom

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-7prpWLlqjahndKhF7n8IIXsHWBcaH8okbNiUXctgow/edit

Working Thesis: Learning outside the classroom is a very good way of not only understanding the topic of discussion but a great way for interactive learning off the campus of your studies. There are many different ways to learn something outside the classroom that still has a way of teaching you on what your learning inside the classroom. When learning off campus and for the community  of West Chester it can not only help you but it also gets you involved in something bigger than yourself, doing stuff for your community can make you learn a thing or too and help you become a better member of your community. For example, internships are a great way to get yourself involved in working a job that you could possibly have after college. This will help you prepare for your future job to come and will also give you a better learning experience instead of being in a classroom talking about it because with an internship it is all hands on work and you are actually doing the job not just talking about it in a classroom.

4 Main Ideas:

1. 1 main idea for this topic is internships. Internships are literally the best way of helping you learn what you have to do for a job inside your major of choice. It is a hands on experience which is why it is so effective it can help you understand what you could possibly be doing in the future with a degree in the major of your choice and it also prepares you in no other way that a teacher could in a classroom.

2.Getting involved in the on campus community and off campus community can help anyone in any major because activities outside the classroom with other students and community members can help build teamwork and other characteristics you will need in a professional job after college. It is so important that a student builds themselves to be able to work as a team, stay organized, and to just do more than what you are doing in your classroom to be more prepared

3.Another great way of learning outside the classroom is the discussion groups that we do for our effective writing class. It is very important that the teacher does not only make time for teacher and student time but also for student and student time. I say this Because students need to interact with each other in order to understand the topic  Better. A student is not going to be able to listen to the teacher all the time they need to interact with other students to discuss the topic in order to understand it better

4. Another way to learn outside the classroom is to get a tutor. A tutor can help with one on one help which can help you understand the topic much more. A tutor can also help you more then the teacher does in a classroom because a lot of students will be  afraid to ask question in a lecture but in a one on one conversation a student is much more likely to ask questions.

Quotes:

“Projecting an absolute ignorance onto others, a characteristic of the ideology of oppression, negates education and knowledge as processes of inquiry. The teacher presents himself to his students as their necessary opposite; by considering their ignorance absolute, he justifies his own existence. The students, alienated like the slave in the Hegelian dialectic, accept their ignorance as justifying the teacher’s existence—but, unlike the slave, they never discover that they educate the teacher.”(P1, PAR 6)

“The capability of banking education to minimize or annul the students’ creative power and to stimulate their credulity serves the interests of the oppressors, who care neither to have the world revealed nor to see it transformed. The oppressors use their “humanitarianism” to preserve a profitable situation. Thus they react almost instinctively against any experiment in education which stimulates the critical faculties and is not content with a partial view of reality but always seeks out the ties which link one point to another and one problem to another.”(P2, PAR 2)

Response to Ruthie’s discussion group.

Group: Katherine Sola, Leann Carroll, myself

In Ruthie’s discussion group we discussed what our motivation is for learning and how we learn best. We all agreed that everybody learns different ways and it is easier for some people to learn one way that may not work for others. The way we learn best is when topics are made interesting, or even making them interesting in your own mind to help motivate you to want to learn. A great way to motivate yourself to learn is working with a group. Work with people who are willing to talk about a topic and want to collaborate. This helps get other people’s point of view and make it more interesting bouncing ideas off of each other. We also talked about the last writing project and reflected on that and the upcoming writing project, discussing the different topics and what we are thinking about writing for them. We all hope to get an A so that we don’t have to write the last one!

Response to Gabby

Group members: Kyle Owens, Bella B, Jake D, Kenzie Neiderer, Jason Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian Galilea, David Heffron, Joshua Rogers, Muhammad Rabi, Jake Heikkinen, Sean Redding, Tyler E, Nick,Timothy Domanowski, Sam Livorno

In this discussion group, we talked about although taking the shortcut seems like the easiest way but there are many disadvantages of taking the shortcuts. We said that people always take shortcuts and then expect the best results for example in the class some students copy answers from other kids and then in the exam then do not get good scores. The reason for that is because they do not put enough effort into it. We also said that professors use same powerpoints over and over again which is easier for them, but is not effective for the students. When someone take shortcuts it doesn’t allow for creativity, and change is a creative process. There is nothing unique left because everyone does the same repeated thing which leaves for no creativeness. People take shortcuts just so they could ignore other people but interacting with others teach you life lessons and makes you a better person.

Project 2 proposal

Topic 4: Team- Kyle Owens
2 sub points – 

Good teaching should include input from the students on how the class is run, as all students have their own unique ways they learn best. College students have been taking classes for years now and are able to identify what learning styles will be most beneficial to them.

Students should have both options of working in groups or working independently, as students benefit from these options differently.  When only one option is used some students are given an advantage, while others are put at a disadvantage. 


Thesis – Professors can support real student learning by being more open to teaching the class a way that will benefit students most, not the professors. 

2 supporting percy ideas- “Avoiding the educators direct presentation of the object as the lesson to be learned.” “The educator is well aware that something is wrong, that there is a fatal gap between the students’ learning and students’ lives.” pg 4

Response to Shawn

Kyle Owens, Bella B, Jake D, Jenna Schreiber, Jason Gabby, Shawn, Jenna, Sabrina, Cristian Galilea, David Heffron, Joshua Rogers, Muhammad Rabi, Jake Heikkinen, Sean Redding, Tyler E, Nick, Timothy Domanowski, Sam Livorno

This discussion group was very large, and since two people had similar topics we combined into one big group. The topic was about how short cuts that we take actually hurt us in the long run. This was shown by us memorizing in school. We do this so that way we can pass the test, but in the long run this is not effective because we actually do not learn anything. We also talked about how some professors use the same powerpoints year after year to save themselves time. This is not effective because the students are not the same every year. For students this can also be shown by when taking a math test we would much rather plug everything into a calculator and let it do the work. By doing this we are not learning anything other than how to press a button. We also do not have any work shown so if we get the answer wrong we cannot receive any credit. We also would rather ask Google for the answer to our homework problems, then to actually figure it out for ourselves. This does not help us because come time for the exam we do not know how to do complex problems because we cannot ask google. All these examples prove that taking short cuts actually hurts us, rather than helps us.

css.php