https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Hnnz3XMooztsXfLSuEXholpTXzpVBOCM4iN07W_8-ok/edit?usp=sharing
Month: November 2019
Peer Review- Draft 1 for Luke J
Praise:
Makayla- I like how you used a quote in your intro
Maura- The connection between West Chester, the problem, the solution, and Percy is strong.
Gwen- Your off to a really good start I think that your paragraphs are strong especially your intro
Constructive:
Makayla- Type the full number (twelve- fourteen)
Maura- try to work on your transition from paragraph to paragraph
Gwen- avoid talking in first person
Percy:
Makayla- This is a good quote in connecting Percy to your idea of students shadowing other students
Maura- The explanation you had with this quote is very good and backs up your idea
Gwen- I think connecting Frier and Percy in your essay is a great idea because it adds more evidence
Comments for Makayla’s Teams Draft
Positive: I like the idea of getting involved for students to receive a better experience
Negative: Just be a little more specific with this point. I like the idea just be more specific and expand on it.
Percy: I like this quote because of the depth of it. It talks about how a rare student understands how this works. You have to really dive deep into it
Emily Foley Mia Citerone Draft 2
Comments for Jake Drap’s Teams 1st draft
Positive: I like your point about internships leading to job opportunities and opening doors
Negative: this seems very broad. I would advise to be a little more specific with this subpoena
Percy: Not sure how this quote directly relates to your topic. It may be hard to incorporate this
Draft Review on Ava Hill
Praise: You have an extremely strong thesis that covers a wide range of topics that could place “students in the driver’s seat”
Constructive: Check the punctuation you are using and make sure that they are being used properly. You could also use a different type of punctuation if it works better.
Percy: The use of your quotes through the whole essay are great at relating back to your main point of the paragraph. Just remember to cite where they came from in the final draft.
Draft 1 Review
Nik Passias
Praise: I like your subtopics and how they connect to the topic you want to discuss.
Constructive: Maybe try to get your format of the essay together because it kind of feels all over.
Percy: Good usage of Percy in a part of essay.
Draft Review on Abigail Johnson’s Team
Praise: You have the ideas down which relate to the main topic you are trying to prove.
Construction: Check over your grammar to make sure the sentences read well.
Percy: Add some quotes to back up your points in the body paragraphs.
Draft Review 1 Nick
Nick Gamba’s Group
Praise: Your topics that you dicuss throughout the paper were good.
Constructive: Towards the end it was kind of short maybe expand more of what you are saying.
Percy: You have very strong percy quotes tom support your claim.
Draft 1
Abigal Johnsons Draft Peer review
Praise:Thesis draws in the reader.
Constructive: Project is short and leaves room for questions
Percy: I saw little use of percy.
Peer Review for Haley Myers’ Draft
Positive: I think you have really good ideas and I think they work really well in your essay.
Constructive: I think you thesis maybe too wordy and readers may have a hard time following.
Percy: I like the quotes you chose from Percy and I think they explain your ideas really well.
Peer Review for Ava Hill’s Draft
Positive: I really like your ideas and overall I think they are good ways to teach without actually teaching.
Constructive: Maybe start your paragraph where you are explaining your subpoints, with exactly what you subpoints is, so readers don’t have to search for what each paragraph is about.
Percy: I liked the quotes you chose from Percy and they helped prove your ideas. I also like the quotes you chose from Freire too.
Ava Hills Draft Peer Review
Praise: The connection between Percy and Freire is strong and the way you use it strengthens your essay.
Constructive:At times sentences seemed to run on and i lost my train of thought.
Percy: Your use and quotes of Persey relate to your essay well but it would help to cite them to pages etc.
Peer Review for Haley, Seamus and David
Use of Percy: Good use of Percy in your thesis to introduce the reader to what your writing about
Positive: I think these are good ways that students can continue to learn outside of the classroom
constructive: I think clubs is a good idea but what would these clubs do to help students really learn? Maybe provide an example of a club we have here at WCU and relate it to what your writing about.
Peer review of Kenzie and Jenna
Negative: I would try to elaborate more in your thesis. It is kind of confusing what you are going to be talking about
Positive: I think this is a great example of Friere that relates to your topic nicely. It fits with the Percy quote you used above it. I would try to say more about it though afterwards.
Use of Percy: This is a good use of Percy in your essay and your understanding of it is good as well. It adds to your essay.
draft reviews
Makayla, Maura, Gwen
Praise- off to a good start, you have goos examples throughout your essay Constructive- maybe give an example or two on how classes could benefit from a real experience
Percy- quotes are good they fit well in your essay and with your topic.
Sabrina Lindley
praise- you have a really good opening paragraph and a very well thought out essay
constructive- words are a little repetitive throughout the essay
Percy- all of your quotes are really good and fit well with all of your examples
Ruthie Lohmann Draft Peer Review
David:
Praise: your intro paragraph is a great, its a good way to start your audience and let them know what the subject of the paper is.
Constructive: You. may have indented some of your paragraphs a little to much.
Percy: your quotes work perfect with the sub-topics you have chosen.
Seamus:
Praise: I like how you started the essay off with Socrates to reference teaching
Constructive: Maybe shorten the intro paragraph so it doesn’t take up too much of the essay
Percy: You used many quotes to support modern solutions to the role of the teacher
Haley Clark:
Praise: Good point on how teachers should be a facilitator
Constructive: Possibly use more quotes to support solutions
Percy: Quotes used very effectively in the first paragraph
Nick Gamba’s Draft Peer Review
David:
Praise: Your subtopics completely support your thesis
Constructive: your paragraph format is just how you need it to get a good grade. Make sure you have no grammatical errors
Percy: your quotes support the sub topics well.
Seamus:
Praise: I like your statement that field trips or visual learning can give you better learning
Constructive: Maybe reference Percy or start with a question in the intro paragraph to make it stronger
Percy: Your Percy quote supports your field trip solution well
Haley:
Haley Clarke
Praise: I agree with your statement that discussion panels are a great way for people to have an opinion
constructive: your paper is well formatted but you might want to add a little more bulk to the last two paragraphs
Percy: your knowledge from the readings of Percy showed greatly in your paragraphs when comparing Percy to your sub-topic
Emily’s Team Review
Constructive:
Your thesis needs more detail. Discuss what the better education package is before body paragraph maybe?

Sam Livorno
Praise:
Your Body paragraph 1 is well written and clearly gets your idea across.

Sam Livorno
Percy:
You guys quote the text and support your writing very well.