Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/digitalw/wrt120.digitalwcu.org/WeeklyBlogs/wp-config.php on line 101
Weekly Responses – Page 38 – Weekly Writing & Blogs

Response to Jason

Jason R, Liz s, Ju B, Timothy D, riley B, Maddie B, ruthie L, Jake h, Sean R, nick P, Christian j, Micheal R, jake D, Muh R

In our discussion group we will talk about the differences between banking education and problem-posing education. We also discussed the strengths and weaknesses between the two. The banking education system is not efficient because of how passive you are and you potentially aren’t actually learning. In high school the banking education was mainly model that the teacher taught you to do good on the test less of learning the actual information. You memorize everything your teacher taught you, use it for the test, and then all the information you retained is gone. We talked about how most people are forced to take classes and go to college that they really don’t want to be at and learn. This causes a forced learning style, making not want to go to school and get an educational. This is better then the banking education method. Problem Posing education is getting students to do more and get involved in a learning environment. Banking education is when the teacher just talks and is teaching you while ur sitting in a classroom, and your supposed to obtain all the information the professor talks about. Problem posing forces students to use critical thinking and talking about in groups with other peers.

discussion 3 response

Ruthie L, Jake H, Sean R, Nick P, Christian G, Michael R, Jake D, Gabby L, Jason R, Liya S, Juliana B, Timothy D, Riley B, Maddie B

In our discussion we talked about banking education and problem-posing education and their strengths/weaknesses. We also talked about how the education system could be improved. I think it’s important for us to take ownership of our education. Freire compares students to containers and talks about how we are forced to just memorize all this information without really doing anything with it. Students are not really involved in their education. Just memorizing facts and restating them, over time they will easily be forgotten. I think that in order to truly learn, we need to use information and engage in it. Different activities or involving the students in the topic, rather than the teacher just speaking and memorizing, would be much more effective. Students should tie what they’re learning to their everyday life. By making these connections, the student will be able to remember the information much easier.

Discussion Group Jason R.

Jason R. Leaha S. Juliana B. Timothy D. Riley B. Maddie E. Muhamed R. Ruthie L. Jake H. Sean R. Christian G. Micheal R. David. Jake D. Gabby L. Nik P. 

Problem posing is a better way of learning because it makes students think about what they’re learning and having to learn. Banking information is just memorizing and you wind up forgetting things after just memorizing over and over again. We related to highschool being how you memorized over and over for a test and then didnt actually keep the information you learned. College gen ed classes could work the same way, why save information for something youll never need in life? Usually students just remember what they can for a test and then forget about it for the future. Colleges want more of your money and time which forces you to take these classes where you just bank the information but never actually learn it. People don’t follow their passions and  they wind up doing a job they dont love doing. After all our discussion we all agreed problem posing works better than banking information and it would change some of the problems mentioned before. 

Response to Samantha Pawluczyk

Our discussion group started with the question, “Is in-class learning or hands on experience more beneficial to students?” We could all agree that hands-on, real life experience is more beneficial. For example, in a science class you can talk about formulas all you want, but you might not actually understand what you are learning until you perform an experiment. We also said that, in real life experiences, you will mess up and be able to learn from your mistakes, but if you mess up on a test you won’t get a second chance. We also all agreed that we are visual learners, so that hands-on learning works best for us. But, we did consider that some students might not enjoy this type of learning if the are more reserved and don’t really like to participate. The down side of that though, is that some students could just be trying to get an A and aren’t actually retaining the information they are given. Then they face the problem of memorizing, but not actually learning.

Laura McGroary

Mike Tresoikas

Meghan Kidd

Samantha Pawlucsyk

Writing Assignment

David MacMullen

Professor Cream

Writing 120

9/19/19

Topic: The topic I plan to choose is number 3. I will compose a comparison on my relationship at West Chester with my professors to this topic. I will explain how one on one interactions or communicative classrooms can help a professor build relations with their students to help them succeed despite the difference in race, class, and gender. I will use Friere’s ideas on the concepts of education by comparing those ideas to how a modern classroom is nowadays.

Group Members: Seamus Corkery and Haley Clark

Thesis Statement: Student/Teacher relations is a very complex relationship because teachers can’t produce student learning or student freedom. For a teacher to truly enlighten a student with the knowledge they can gain they must learn how to personalize their classroom as a communicative and interacting environment.

Quotes: “Education thus becomes an act of depositing, in which the students are the depositories and the teacher is the depositor. Instead of communicating, the teacher issues communiqués and makes deposits which the students patiently receive, memorize, and repeat. This is the “banking” concept of education, in which the scope of action allowed to the students extends only as far as receiving, filing, and storing the deposits.” (Par. 3 Pg. 1)

“But the humanist, revolutionary educator cannot wait for this possibility to materialize. From the outset, her efforts must coincide with those of the students to engage in critical thinking and the quest for mutual humanization. His efforts must be imbued with a profound trust in people and their creative power. To achieve this, they must be partners of the students in their relations with them” (Par. 7 Pg. 2)

Response to Brandon

Brandon, Gabe, Sara, Cait, Seamus, Haley, David, Sam, Amanda, Katherine

In our discussion group today we talked about how Freire thinks people learn and if we agree or disagree. We agreed that throughout Freire’s article he contradicts himself many times in his writing. He explains that to be taught you must learn from yourself and dig deep into things to actually learn from yourself. By what Freire says I think he means, to learn something you must understand it deeply enough that you can teach it to someone else so that you can fully take it in and understand it yourself. I do not agree with him. I believe that people can learn from each other. From face to face interaction and communication with somebody else. During our discussion we also talked about housing on and off campus, just because it came up. Many of us are looking for apartments next year, but they are very expensive so we will see where everybody ends up.

Response to Brandon Zahal

Today my discussion group and I discussed the topic if we agree or disagree on the different ways Freire believes students learn. As a group we all believed that yes the banking concept is one of the many ways a student learns, but we also agreed that this is to the only way that students can learn. some other ways that we felt are how students learn is through one on one interaction which we thought was a great way for students to learn because when one on one with a teacher it is easier for the teacher to interact with the learner and this makes it more efficient for the student to get the concept of the subject. Another way a student can learn is through group activities. Group activities are great because it not only gives you and your peers a challenge as you work on a project or a discussion together. But it also gives each and every student a chance to hear the different opinions of the other students. When being able to listen to other students talk it gives every other student a chance to learn from someone that is in the same shoes as you. That is why I believe that the discussion groups we are doing for effective writing is such a. good idea. Without the discussion groups I do not think that I would understand the concepts of the readings we’ve been doing if it wasn’t for the discussion groups

Group:

Haley Clark 

Brandon Zahal – leader

Sarah Veneziale

Sam wheitzel

David Macmullen

Shamus Corkery

Gabe jsinskn

Amanda jieng

Catherine Sola 

Response to Bella DiPasquale

group members: maura, qwen, david, julia, emily, amanda, ava, mia, john, mikayla

In our discussion we talked about how people are able to learn effectively and what is not effective for learning. Freire talks about how people cannot learn in an environment where a teacher is just lecturing at the students. Freire says one cannot teach someone else and you cannot teach yourself. We discussed how people can not formulate knowledge and you can only learn by communicating with two or more people. In order to learn you have to engage in conversation to get something out of it. You learn by talking out loud and obtaining the information you are saying yourself. You in a way teach yourself by having intelligent conversations with other people. You can also solve your own problems by just talking out loud to another person and hearing yourself talk. By listening to your self talk you also give yourself advise and essentially solve your problems yourself. Overall people cannot be taught by having information jammed into there head without even saying a word abt the information.

Response to Bella

On September 19 at 3:40 my group discussed how no one teaches others, and how people don’t teach themselves. This means that you don’t learn by being taught, but you learn from teaching others. When students are lectured, they don’t learn, because the teacher is just spewing facts and information at them and they can’t apply the information they’re being taught. Learning is understanding the topic, and you don’t understand it until you apply it to the real world. Also, to learn, you must engage in the conversation and topic that you are learning about. The best way to learn is through communication. Freire’s “Banking Concept of learning” says that teachers aren’t able to teach students by sharing information in a classroom. Teachers think that repeating information over and over again will help the student learn, but it doesn’t. People mainly learn by teaching others the information and applying it to real life experiences. 

Group: Bella, Gwen Jordan, Maura Kelly, Mia C., Emily, Julia D, Amanda, ava hill, Ethan s, David h, olivia

Response To Bella D.

Bella D. (Leader), Amanda R., Maura K., David H., Ethan S., Gwen J., Mia C., John A., Emily F.

In our discussion we talked about Freire’s quote “here no one teachers another, nor is anyone taught. People teach each other.” We discussed how no one teaches each other and no one teaches themselves, but instead learning is done through communication of two people, where only one person is truly learning. What happens is you take your knowledge and give it to others through communication, you instead learn from teaching but not by being taught. Everyone learns and understands differently, and so in order to learn you must talk to another person, but only for your own self learning. We learn from our own personal experiences, not from what is being taught to us… you can not formulate knowledge. Engaging in a conversation, communicating with another person and speaking with that person is learning.

Response to Bella

On September 19, 2019, we discussed how no one teaches another and how people do not teach themselves. We talked about how you cannot take knowledge and hand it to someone or they will not get it. People learn by teaching others not by being taught. We said by handing people knowledge, no one learns. Knowledge can’t be given out to students. The students can’t sit in a class and absorb information. We also said people learn from personal, real world experiences. Knowledge is not something you can formulate. Instead, it is shared through communication. Speaking and communication are learning. In order to teach, everyone has to be engaged in conversation. This relates to Freire’s essay because he wrote about how teachers are not capable of teaching students by sharing information in a classroom. Teaching is not handing information to someone; it is something obtained from actually experiencing things and learning from that. Group:

Bella, Maura, Makayla, Emily, Mia, Julia, John, Ava, Amanda, Ethan, David

Response to bella

During our discussion we talking about how no one teaches another and no one self teaches either. This statement is saying that you learn from experiences and not from other people. You can’t just throw your knowledge at other people because they won’t always understand the way you are explaining it. You can’t teach yourself because you aren’t just born with knowledge and you learn through experiences. Communication teaches how to work through life. Everyone learns in different ways so when they experience something in life they explain it in different ways. By handing people knowledge they won’t always understand it. Learning something is through real world experiences. In order to understand both sides of the conversation have to engage in what is being said. Learning is understanding and understanding is learning. This discussion was helpful because I got to see other people’s view on what Freire is saying in his essay. 

Leader: Bella 

Followers: Gwen, Makayla, Liv, Amanda , Ethan, Ava, David, John, Mia, Julia, Emily 

Response to Bellas discussion 3

Group Members: Mia, Emily, Maura, Gwen, Julia, Bella (Leader), John, Amanda, Ava, Amanda, David H, Ethan, Liv

During this weeks discussion, we talked about how nobody teaches another and nobody teaches themselves. This relates back to Freire’s banking concept of education. We learn by teaching other people , but they do not learn by listening to us because people do not learn from listening, they learn from experiences. We learn more by trying to teach or explain something to somebody. It may make sense to the person explaining, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that the listener will learn from that. They may retain the information and process what someone s trying to teach, but they may have a different point of view and develop a whole new concept.

“You can’t give someone a shit sandwich” You can’t learn from being taught, but you can learn from teaching other people.

Communicating will help someone learn. Everyone processes and learns differently. For example, I did not understand what this discussion was about completely until we all talked about it. Everyone gave a piece of what they thought Freire was trying to say and developed an understanding by conferring and making up my own view of this topic. Nobody fully understood the what this discussion was about until we further talked about it. Thus, learning from ourselves explaining to each other.

Response to Brandon’s Discussion

  In Brandon’s discussion our group talked about whether we agreed or disagreed with Freire’s way of learning. In his writing, it seems he makes points that contradicts himself and the things he says. A quote found in his writing that best supports my claim is, “Here, no one teaches another, nor is anyone self taught. People teach each other…”. I believe this quote is very contradicting and requires a deep thought process in order to understand. From what I understand, Freire is trying to explain that one cannot be taught by a teacher or a student, one must find it within themselves to be taught information that is being told to them by teachers or any form of educator.
Aside of Freire, we also discussed all of our living situations currently and for the following year. Most of us are looking to rent an apartment or house off-campus, but are discovering that it is really expensive. 

In conclusion, our group discussed several key facts in Freire’s work and we pretty much all disagreed with the content he proclaims in his writings.

Group Members: Brandon, Gabe, Sara, Cait, Seamus, Haley, David, Sam, Amanda, Sam

response to Brandon’s topic

our group: sarah veneziale, cait mangini, seamus corkery, haley clark, sam livoreno, brandon vagal, gabe jasinski, sam weitzel, amanda, katherine

In our discussion group, we talked about Freire’s thoughts on how humans learn. He believes that the only way one can learn is by having another person with them but not talking as they say what they want to learn. This can be used for school or problems in life. I have done this many times when I read aloud an essay or talk about problems to someone and realize the solution or mistake as I am talking. We agreed that this can be a way to learn, but not the only way. Humans can learn through their mistakes and real life experiences as well. We are constantly learning about ourselves and our surroundings on our own. We can also learn through others. Unlike what Freire would say, teachers can actually teach students something and they will understand and use it as new information. Friends can give very helpful information to another, and teach them something new. There are several ways to learn, not only one.

Writing Assignment

Sam Livorno 

23, September 2019

Professor Cream

WRT 120

Writing Assignment 1

Topic Selection: I plan to dive into topic three for my writing assignment. I plan to explain the gap between the teacher and student at WCU, what causes this, how students can communicate with their professors, regardless of their gender/race/class. Of course, I will compare and relate these subjects to Freire’s “The Banking Concept of Education” and his views on the student/teacher relationship. 

Group members: None 

Thesis: In Paul Freire’s passage, “The Banking Concept of Education”, he discusses the displacement of the relationship between the student and teacher, “Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction”; until this “contradiction” is mended through communication, compassion, and effort from both the student and teacher, no learning will take place.     

Quotes:  Page 1, paragraph 7, line 2 “ Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction, by reconciling the poles of the contradiction so that both are simultaneously teachers and students.”

  Page 2, paragraph 3, line 1 “Indeed, the interests of the oppressors lie in “changing the consciousness of the oppressed, not the situation which oppresses them”; for the more the oppressed can be led to adapt to that situation, the more easily they can be dominated.”

“Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction”

Response to Brandon Zahal

Group members- Cait Mangini, David Macmullen, Sam Livorno, Sarah Veneziale, Gabe , Sam Weitzel, Seamus Corkery, Amanda, Katherine

In today’s discussion group we talked about Freire’s way of learning, and whether or not we agree with his principles. Freire believes the only way for a person to learn is to teach something to someone else. However, the person being taught doesn’t learn, only the teacher. The group discussed how Friere’s way of learning could be a good way to understand and attain more knowledge about yourself. However, it is not the only way someone can grasp a concept. Everyone learns differently, some through experience, some read or have good memorization skills. Everyone’s brain retains information differently. It was also said how Freire seems to contradict himself quite a lot, which can make it hard to trust anything he has said, and believe the ideas he presented. We also discussed some things about writing project one, and what is due in class on Monday.

Response to Brandon Zahal

By Seamus Corkery

Group Members- Cait Mangini, David Macmullen, Sam Livorno, Hailey Clark, Brandon Zahal, Sarah Veneziale, Gabe, Sam Weitzel, Amanda, Kathryn

For this discussion group we discussed Freire’s ideologies about how people learn. Freire’s ideology about how people learn is that people cannot be taught by someone else, but they cannot be self-taught. This is a tricky point because it seems contradictory, but it’s not. He’s saying that to be taught you must go to someone else and learn from what you tell the person even if they don’t give you an answer. Our group personally disagreed with Freire because we felt that he contradicted himself when explaining how we as students learn. I personally felt that you can learn from others and yourself but I think you you learn through his ideology. Overall we felt that the way that students learn is specific to the student. All students learn differently and some students learn more than other students depending on how they’re learning. To conclude, we feel that students should learn whatever way works best for them.

Week three discussion topic

Participants: Brandon (leader), Sam, David, Sara, Cate, Haley, Sam, Sheamus, Amanda, Katherine, Gabe (me)

Today’s topic that Brandon brought forward was whether or not we as individuals agreed with Freire’s learning concept. While at first the conversation bounced from how we interpreted his banking concept, which for many saw people as objects that are designed for a sole purpose later in life, for instance teaching someone accounting all their life just for them to become a bank teller or some sort of account at a business, with no other reason other than to be a resource for a larger organization. The conversation pivoted towards how it seemed Freire contradicted himself intentionally, while this didn’t delve deeper into anything more than this point, it did remind me of something my FYE class had presented as a question, what is the difference between a student and a learner. Thinking of this, I began to answer the question to myself and how this correlated towards the conversation, I believe that a student is an individual that is designed to become a resource, while a learner can utilize both practical and vital skill sets that advance their understanding of the world around them. Having answered this I pieced together the idea that Freire sees all learners as students with the potential to become a full fledged learner.

Response to Haley

Group members: Sabrina

In this discussion, the main focus was learning through being social. As a whole, we agreed that when learning it is easier to learn when more people are talking. We felt that when a teacher is the only one talking it could affect the students. The students may not like classes that are just lectures. It could make the students be less involved and be lazy. It doesn’t have to be everyone talking but as long as some people are talking it will keep more people involved. Also talking during class will get you to know your classmates better. When you know your classmates better it could help you be engaged with them. The more you know your classmates the more you’re likely to bounce ideas off theirs. If you put your ideas out there this could benefit the class. The more ideas it is more likely for a student to understand something because they may have different learning styles.

css.php